{"speech_score":["1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","","","","","","","","","","","","","","","","","","","","","","","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1"],"media_score":[["0.1_1",["406851150202-3542-87e6-5c01-0739-86611769838759797#0.1#10050171#0#0##","53.39","53.28","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that belittles a person","false"]],["1.1_1",["406851150202-cd38-2353-3edc-258e-69691769838772113#1.1#10050171#0#0##","67.74","53.57","0","","25","or persons because they belong (even allegedly) to a certain social group.","false"]],["2.1_1",["406851150202-7334-e641-fee4-bc24-90fe1769838782481#2.1#10050171#0#0##","56.23","32.26","0","","25","That group may have attributes such as race, ethnicity, gender,","false"]],["3.1_1",["406851150202-bccc-8a43-dcb5-2653-39ba1769838793600#3.1#10050171#0#0##","91.57","70.66","0","","25","sexual orientation, religion, age, physical or mental disability and others.","false"]],["4.1_1",["406851150202-8947-029a-678c-0b5a-c2b41769838802119#4.1#10050171#0#0##","93.46","64.58","0","","25","Typical hate speech involves labels and slurs,","false"]],["5.1_1",["406851150202-b1fe-4fbd-5046-cfef-28791769838809950#5.1#10050171#0#0##","92.98","51.93","0","","25","or statements that promote malicious stereotypes.","false",[["60.888000000000005","90",["EH=>I"],"stereotypes"]]]],["6.1_1",["406851150202-cbac-9c74-0717-21e8-00421769838818155#6.1#10050171#0#0##","92.25","55.64","0","","25","Hate speech is often intended to incite","false",[["1.044","90",["IH=>I"],"is"]]]],["7.1_1",["406851150202-ddaa-c53b-ae58-0426-47d01769838824407#7.1#10050171#0#0##","90","39.59","0","","25","hatred or violence against a group.","false",[["39.176","90",["V=>B"],"violence"]]]],["8.1_1",["406851150202-9188-90e6-77ff-db95-0c0a1769838834707#8.1#10050171#0#0##","93.44","65.38","0","","25","Hate speech can also include unspoken pictures and symbols.","false"]],["9.1_1",["406851150202-d712-ce48-7c8c-e79c-da6d1769838840496#9.1#10050171#0#0##","94.31","70.88","0","","25","For example,","false"]],["10.1_1",["406851150202-34b5-e1d7-5455-3be4-33581769838851531#10.1#10050171#0#0##","66.4","43.66","0","","25","the Nazi swastika and the Confederate battle flag (of the Confederate States","false"]],["11.1_1",["406851150202-efc9-4f9a-905e-7641-156c1769838862084#11.1#10050171#0#0##","44.72","35.83","0","","25","of America) have been considered hate speech by many people and groups.","false"]],["12.1_1",["406851150202-4ca3-7df0-4781-16c9-6cd11769838869237#12.1#10050171#0#0##","12.59","60.08","0","","25","Critics of hate speech argue that","false"]],["12.1_2",["406851150202-f98a-ae94-232a-5015-6a821769838878273#12.1#10050171#0#0##","43.07","53.89","0","","25","Critics of hate speech argue that","false"]],["13.1_1",["406851150202-349f-a88e-e9b1-9836-7bcd1769838886426#13.1#10050171#0#0##","56.83","67.34","0","","25","it causes psychological harm to its victims,","false"]],["14.1_1",["406851150202-c7ce-9994-e7dc-6c50-37911769838894913#14.1#10050171#0#0##","76.19","65.98","0","","25","and physical harm when it incites violence.","false"]],["15.1_1",["406851150202-b1d3-0254-f075-18a6-5bd51769838902102#15.1#10050171#0#0##","28.75","45.43","0","","25","They also say that it makes","false"]],["15.1_2",["406851150202-5721-7a66-0645-f676-d97c1769838909384#15.1#10050171#0#0##","50.19","59.11","0","","25","They also say that it makes","false"]],["16.1_1",["406851150202-67b4-ca02-7697-54b4-f5ca1769838916489#16.1#10050171#0#0##","73.07","54.15","0","","25","its victims less equal in society.","false"]],["17.1_1",["406851150202-83e4-e8e8-b3bb-b884-97011769838923712#17.1#10050171#0#0##","70.37","33.72","0","","25","That is particularly true, they claim,","false"]],["18.1_1",["406851150202-692b-4f92-aabe-bff7-61ed1769838931714#18.1#10050171#0#0##","79.37","60.51","0","","25","because the social groups that are commonly the targets of","false"]],["19.1_1",["406851150202-d806-853c-a3e4-24b8-f4691769838942852#19.1#10050171#0#0##","70.85","85.87","0","","25","hate speech have historically suffered from social marginalization and oppression.","false",[["76.256","85.32",["E+I=>A"],"hate"]]]],["20.1_1",["406851150202-0ad6-21c6-7bcd-b0c6-cb801769838953527#20.1#10050171#0#0##","43.2","33.36","0","","25","Hate speech therefore poses a challenge for modern liberal societies,","false"]],["21.1_1",["406851150202-9311-d201-34b6-e469-26a21769838962796#21.1#10050171#0#0##","92.46","70.66","0","","25","which are committed to both freedom","false"]],["22.1_1",["406851150202-5cb6-adc6-2813-8c5d-89411769838970316#22.1#10050171#0#0##","92.94","87.14","0","","25","of expression and social equality.","false",[["79.176","90",["V=>B"],"of"]]]],["23.1_1",["406851150202-a4dd-719b-a28d-a0e5-95cb1769838976600#23.1#10050171#0#0##","90","32.3","0","","25","Thus,","false",[["64.456","90",["AH=>O","S=>SH"],"Thus"]]]],["24.1_1",["406851150202-7c65-227a-0aa1-4781-0f611769838985708#24.1#10050171#0#0##","59.66","82.51","0","","25","there is an ongoing debate in those societies over whether","false"]],["25.1_1",["406851150202-4c8e-2d56-c265-860a-f8531769838996582#25.1#10050171#0#0##","78.44","72.97","0","","25","and how hate speech should be regulated or censored.","false"]],["26.1_1",["406851150202-dd51-f89a-9da3-f34d-b86d1769839004821#26.1#10050171#0#0##","34.2","20.18","0","","25","Censorship Is Worse Than Hate Speech","false"]],["27.1_1",["406851150202-a954-c3d3-7146-7000-682c1769839015942#27.1#10050171#0#0##","93.26","79.57","0","","25","In the idea of what traditional liberal,","false"]],["28.1_1",["406851150202-325b-e4da-4459-39f6-755c1769839022648#28.1#10050171#0#0##","29.48","72.31","0","","25","democratic societies should be,","false"]],["28.1_2",["406851150202-8ac8-89ad-5e21-6251-94801769839030467#28.1#10050171#0#0##","93.5","89.62","0","","25","democratic societies should be,","false",[["77.104","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"societies"]]]],["29.1_1",["406851150202-cd68-6105-b1af-2dcd-38251769839038921#29.1#10050171#0#0##","68.63","24.71","0","","25","all speech is typically allowed","false",[["9.738","90",["Z=>S"],"is"]]]],["30.1_1",["406851150202-af36-7fc9-c05d-b631-81d41769839047391#30.1#10050171#0#0##","91.86","58.52","0","","25","under the ideal of \"freedom of expression.\"","false"]],["31.1_1",["406851150202-1b3d-2b62-b23d-b222-c1481769839054797#31.1#10050171#0#0##","64.8","52.88","0","","25","That often includes hate speech.","false",[["77.968","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"includes"]]]],["32.1_1",["406851150202-1f74-a14d-0b59-90b9-91d01769839063077#32.1#10050171#0#0##","58.84","53.92","0","","25","A person may be disgusted by hate speech,","false"]],["33.1_1",["406851150202-af90-1d03-6716-1c7b-c2af1769839070320#33.1#10050171#0#0##","42.86","69.82","0","","25","but they may also find it worse to allow","false"]],["34.1_1",["406851150202-6fa3-7875-700c-02bd-f61d1769839078656#34.1#10050171#0#0##","48.59","47.19","0","","25","their government to censor the words of a citizen,","false"]],["34.1_2",["406851150202-6942-e9df-f565-d767-ecb11769839087761#34.1#10050171#0#0##","41.74","48.88","0","","25","their government to censor the words of a citizen,","false"]],["35.1_1",["406851150202-b573-355c-3a05-adc9-2c361769839107502#35.1#10050171#0#0##","36.42","60.67","0","","25","even if those words are bigoted or hateful. Censorship,","false"]],["35.1_2",["406851150202-b573-355c-3a05-adc9-2c361769839107502#35.1#10050171#0#0##","36.42","60.67","0","","25","even if those words are bigoted or hateful. Censorship,","false"]],["35.1_3",["406851150202-91f7-f7ba-76e9-fcde-70c31769839118172#35.1#10050171#0#0##","34.85","51.08","0","","25","even if those words are bigoted or hateful. Censorship,","false"]],["35.1_4",["406851150202-43bc-52fd-0b12-b47c-a4711769839136505#35.1#10050171#0#0##","55.57","45.44","0","","25","even if those words are bigoted or hateful. Censorship,","false"]],["36.1_1",["406851150202-01a4-a083-cc48-5c3f-2cbb1769839142906#36.1#10050171#0#0##","52.88","55.97","0","","25","they might say,","false",[["5.0760000000000005","0",["EH=>I"],"lead"]]]],["37.1_1",["406851150202-ddba-e273-5ada-e996-43671769839150324#37.1#10050171#0#0##","57.08","46.25","0","","25","would lead to more censorship by a government.","false"]],["38.1_1",["406851150202-e3b3-b1d2-33ba-6982-ea931769839156646#38.1#10050171#0#0##","95.48","74.51","0","","25","It could end up that legitimate","false"]],["39.1_1",["406851150202-e99a-2c9a-823a-57a2-458c1769839164418#39.1#10050171#0#0##","50.62","54.59","0","","25","but unpopular expression would be disallowed,","false",[["0.12","0",["AH=>O","V=>B"],"of"]]]],["39.1_2",["406851150202-1a12-8a2a-d9e4-4356-768c1769839171269#39.1#10050171#0#0##","92.92","62.73","0","","25","but unpopular expression would be disallowed,","false"]],["40.1_1",["406851150202-8e7d-d70c-a57c-f493-9e061769839179923#40.1#10050171#0#0##","71.38","56.75","0","","25","such as criticism of government. This would be unthinkable,","false"]],["63.1_1",["406851150202-8c3d-cb57-7365-302b-435f1769839845550#63.1#10050171#0#0##","38.48","43.5","0","","25","it also continues the oppression of these minorities.","false",[["73.336","90",["S=>SH"],"also"],["0.12","0",["DH=>D"],"the"],["45.2","90",["DH=>D","Z=>S"],"these"],["16.116","90",["Z=>S"],"minorities"]]]],["63.1_2",["406851150202-ba85-4ee0-3646-db45-d4571769839854340#63.1#10050171#0#0##","75.79","73.73","0","","25","it also continues the oppression of these minorities.","false",[["79.23200000000001","90",["S=>SH"],"also"],["9.102","90",["DH=>D","Z=>S"],"these"],["62.6","90",["Z=>S"],"minorities"]]]],["64.1_1",["406851150202-4304-2564-88f0-c5de-4ce21769839859497#64.1#10050171#0#0##","59.4","25.27","0","","25","It causes the victims,","false",[["0.528","0",["AE=>A"],"at"],["48.36000000000001","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["40.304","90",["Z=>S"],"victims"]]]],["65.1_1",["406851150202-270d-22b6-15a3-ca0d-9a461769839868232#65.1#10050171#0#0##","56.71","59.12","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large to","false",[["37.736000000000004","37.17",["AE=>A"],"act"]]]],["66.1_1",["406851150202-eba2-2ed0-a46f-711c-5daa1769839876386#66.1#10050171#0#0##","65.04","62.33","0","","25","internalize the hateful messages and act on that hate.","false",[["72.16799999999999","90",["ER=>I R","Z=>S"],"internalize"],["72.776","90",["AE=>A"],"act"],["0.6360000000000001","90",["DH=>D"],"that"]]]],["67.1_1",["406851150202-af0c-5dd4-8586-661c-ce8b1769839882357#67.1#10050171#0#0##","64.8","0.35","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot","false",[["0.27599999999999997","90",["V=>B"],"Victims"]]]],["68.1_1",["406851150202-ab16-2a79-9460-cb3b-1adc1769839888758#68.1#10050171#0#0##","80.12","61.49","0","","25","enter the \"open marketplace of ideas\"","false",[["59.096000000000004","53.87",["DH=>D","EH=>I"],"them"],["4.464","90",["ER=>I R"],"enter"],["23.892","90",["D=>JH"],"ideas"]]]],["69.1_1",["406851150202-0b94-387f-6b0f-bc26-8fd21769839898270#69.1#10050171#0#0##","41.41","53.52","0","","25","as equal participants to defend themselves. For them, hate speech,","false",[["71.368","90",["Z=>S"],"as"],["0.15000000000000002","0",["I=>IH"],"speech"],["78.03200000000001","90",["DH=>D","Z=>S"],"themselves"],["74.13600000000001","82.67",["DH=>D"],"them"],["37.696","37.12",["IH=>I"],"in"]]]],["70.1_1",["406851150202-03cf-d523-63ec-846b-17241769839905353#70.1#10050171#0#0##","51.76","40.04","0","","25","in addition to a broader system of inequality","false",[["1.938","90",["U=>O"],"to"],["63.128","90",["ER=>I R"],"broader"],["76.08800000000001","90",["I=>IH"],"inequality"],["11.868000000000002","9.78",["IH=>I"],"in"]]]],["71.1_1",["406851150202-2e83-f7fb-4b66-c657-f6da1769839912892#71.1#10050171#0#0##","92.43","41.12","0","","25","and unjust discrimination that burdens the victims,","false",[["77","90",["Z=>S"],"victims"]]]],["72.1_1",["406851150202-0af0-9ea6-0e0f-49c7-14d91769839918645#72.1#10050171#0#0##","91.64","86.76","0","","25","effectively silences them.","false",[["76.968","90",["Z=>S"],"silences"]]]],["73.1_1",["406851150202-3768-e45f-d80c-1895-68c41769839926029#73.1#10050171#0#0##","74.94","34.74","0","","25","The court system of the United States has,","false",[["69.928","90",["AE=>A"],"has"]]]],["74.1_1",["406851150202-e9ef-9edc-bf8c-c84f-f3d31769839932582#74.1#10050171#0#0##","92.87","74.47","0","","25","on the basis of the First Amendment","false",[["51.400000000000006","90",["DH=>D"],"the"]]]],["75.1_1",["406851150202-9346-a534-fb9d-19c6-0bbb1769839938901#75.1#10050171#0#0##","54.29","64.28","0","","25","and its principle of freedom of speech,","false",[["79.016","78.77",["IH=>I","S=>SH"],"its"]]]],["76.1_1",["406851150202-3944-2756-d739-d441-814d1769839947122#76.1#10050171#0#0##","52.42","68.78","0","","25","generally ruled against attempts to censor hate speech.","false",[["78.976","88.72",["DH=>D"],"The"]]]],["77.1_1",["406851150202-d9e9-bb31-2f52-b694-df3d1769839954475#77.1#10050171#0#0##","29.25","46.8","0","","25","The only exceptions are if hate speech is","false",[["39.944","39.93",["IH=>I"],"is"],["6.486000000000001","0",["IH=>I","S=>SH","A+I=>IH"],"incite"]]]],["77.1_2",["406851150202-4a30-aa57-74e7-67df-786b1769839962945#77.1#10050171#0#0##","35.51","49.52","0","","25","The only exceptions are if hate speech is","false",[["0.18000000000000002","0",["IH=>I","S=>SH","A+I=>IH"],"incite"],["36.888","90",["IH=>I"],"is"]]]],["78.1_1",["406851150202-ace6-730c-ee93-681d-a9a31769839971882#78.1#10050171#0#0##","66.32","62.39","0","","25","being used to incite immediate harm to a person or group,","false",[["19.986000000000004","90",["IH=>I"],"being"],["77.928","90",["IH=>I"],"incite"],["77.47200000000001","90",["U=>O"],"to"]]]],["79.1_1",["406851150202-d460-08bd-efa4-d903-f6aa1769839987208#79.1#10050171#0#0##","55.09","59.41","0","","25","or if someone uses \"fighting words\"","false",[["2.34","0",["DH=>D","EH=>I"],"them"]]]],["80.1_1",["406851150202-eb3e-644b-b8df-e485-a71a1769839993260#80.1#10050171#0#0##","95.35","87.23","0","","25","when standing right in front of them.","false",[["72.18400000000001","90",["IH=>I"],"standing"],["51","90",["DH=>D"],"them"]]]],["81.1_1",["406851150202-8e8e-1535-0c29-e972-aa451769840001769#81.1#10050171#0#0##","90","70.24","0","","25","Other liberal democracies such as France, Germany,","false",[["72.808","90",["ER=>I R"],"Other"],["77.952","90",["IH=>I"],"liberal"],["58.704","90",["S=>SH","Z=>S"],"democracies"],["70.536","90",["F=>P","AE=>A"],"France"]]]],["82.1_1",["406851150202-82ed-d5e3-0cb7-34bd-89b51769840009838#82.1#10050171#0#0##","65.52","50.5","0","","25","Canada and New Zealand have","false",[["77.632","90",["AE=>A"],"Canada"],["0.564","0",["AO=>U"],"laws"],["79.144","90",["V=>B"],"have"]]]]]}