{"speech_score":["1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","0"],"media_score":[["0.1_1",["136696150018-75e0-2875-a30a-f573-0b651769930331616#0.1#10050174#0#0##","55.91","41.49","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that denigrates a person or persons","false",[["1.9800000000000002","0",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"],["71.06400000000001","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["0.33","0",["AE=>A","Z=>S"],"as"]]]],["1.1_1",["136696150018-8edb-0cfd-5c9d-f7fa-5c811769930342986#1.1#10050174#0#0##","84.96","62.02","0","","25","on the basis of (alleged) membership in a social group identified by attributes such as race,","false",[["75.56","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["0.13799999999999998","0",["E+I=>A"],"age"]]]],["2.1_1",["136696150018-5cb3-ddb3-b4fa-ef68-a3981769930352955#2.1#10050174#0#0##","71.92","72.31","0","","25","ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age,","false",[["0.5940000000000001","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"religion"]]]],["3.1_1",["136696150018-e61e-923f-5ed2-346e-b3c01769930360022#3.1#10050174#0#0##","69","63.93","0","","25","physical or mental disability and others.","false",[["7.08","90",["Z=>S"],"physical"],["57.00800000000001","90",["ER=>I R","Z=>S"],"others"]]]],["4.1_1",["136696150018-287f-2633-ac7b-0aee-071f1769930368383#4.1#10050174#0#0##","93.67","67.5","0","","25","Typical hate speech involves epithets and slurs,","false",[["0.06","90",["I=>IH"],"speech"],["7.854000000000001","90",["TH=>T"],"epithets"]]]],["5.1_1",["136696150018-4847-8b6f-34ff-40f1-888b1769930375834#5.1#10050174#0#0##","91.01","53.88","0","","25","statements that promote malicious stereotypes","false"]],["6.1_1",["136696150018-8e86-9004-52dc-a756-a77f1769930385607#6.1#10050174#0#0##","58.7","40","0","","25","and speech intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false",[["66.176","90",["IH=>I"],"incite"]]]],["7.1_1",["136696150018-411c-cb5c-cfb4-d5e2-6b0b1769930393938#7.1#10050174#0#0##","64.51","54.57","0","","25","Hate speech can also include nonverbal depictions and symbols.","false",[["66.912","90",["Z=>S"],"symbols"]]]],["8.1_1",["136696150018-34d7-a1c9-9a97-7d3c-09641769930398629#8.1#10050174#0#0##","90","54.27","0","","25","For example,","false",[["65.4","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"example"]]]],["9.1_1",["136696150018-8424-17fe-be24-1783-258d1769930407343#9.1#10050174#0#0##","48.8","32.55","0","","25","the Nazi swastika and the Confederate battle flag (of the Confederate","false",[["0.36000000000000004","90",["IH=>I"],"swastika"],["6.0840000000000005","90",["ER=>I R"],"Confederate"],["76.976","90",["AE=>A"],"battle"]]]],["10.1_1",["136696150018-c3c1-18fc-5e42-e62e-29ed1769930417475#10.1#10050174#0#0##","66.8","51.88","0","","25","States of America) have been considered hate speech by a variety of people and groups.","false",[["78.272","90",["V=>B"],"have"],["0.12","90",["I=>IH"],"speech"],["78.96000000000001","88.7",["V=>B"],"of"]]]],["11.1_1",["136696150018-62c4-1d74-84ee-ad5b-6af71769930427007#11.1#10050174#0#0##","67.62","63.45","0","","25","Critics of hate speech argue not only","false",[["54.224000000000004","90",["AH=>O"],"of"],["73.712","82.14",["IH=>I"],"it"]]]],["12.1_1",["136696150018-ff33-64b3-85ae-cee5-52dc1769930435710#12.1#10050174#0#0##","92.93","66.38","0","","25","that it causes psychological harm to its victims,","false",[["77.856","90",["Z=>S","Z=>S"],"causes"],["0.618","90",["Z=>S"],"victims"]]]],["13.1_1",["136696150018-5d5f-e924-5c26-ea98-2a291769930443023#13.1#10050174#0#0##","58.42","77.87","0","","25","and physical harm when it incites violence,","false",[["0.24","0",["DH=>D"],"that"],["75.792","90",["V=>B"],"violence"]]]],["14.1_1",["136696150018-4b2d-e600-8a4f-d748-f7c31769930449191#14.1#10050174#0#0##","94.93","89.78","0","","25","but also that it undermines","false",[["76.264","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["77.976","90",["AH=>O","ER=>I R"],"undermines"]]]],["15.1_1",["136696150018-bcd5-2618-ed1a-0a1a-d9b61769930456084#15.1#10050174#0#0##","56.56","45.51","0","","25","the social equality of its victims.","false",[["5.0520000000000005","0",["Z=>S"],"is"],["44.888000000000005","90",["IH=>I"],"equality"]]]],["16.1_1",["136696150018-94ee-a7fe-33f8-44d4-051c1769930463079#16.1#10050174#0#0##","9.24","24.6","0","","25","That is particularly true, they claim,","false",[["0.06","90",["DH=>D"],"they"],["0.126","0",["AA=>U"],"commonly"],["0.132","0",["E+I=>A"],"claim"],["0.9119999999999999","0",["AA=>U"],"are"]]]],["16.1_2",["136696150018-7c41-c2c5-31a7-e406-cca71769930470387#16.1#10050174#0#0##","50.4","43.74","0","","25","That is particularly true, they claim,","false",[["73.256","81.57",["DH=>D"],"the"],["0.126","90",["IH=>I","ER=>I R"],"particularly"]]]],["17.1_1",["136696150018-72f2-49d3-c13d-1b6a-dace1769930478166#17.1#10050174#0#0##","80.06","58.05","0","","25","because the social groups that are commonly the targets of","false",[["73.84","90",["IH=>I"],"because"],["8.526000000000002","90",["DH=>D"],"the"]]]],["18.1_1",["136696150018-1f56-2a6e-7899-229e-91571769930488068#18.1#10050174#0#0##","67.09","59.36","0","","25","hate speech have historically suffered from social marginalization and oppression.","false",[["70.776","90",["AE=>A","V=>B"],"have"],["4.608","90",["F=>P"],"from"],["0.12","0",["S=>SH","SH=>S"],"social"]]]],["19.1_1",["136696150018-777f-2480-b18d-14cc-c4f61769930501257#19.1#10050174#0#0##","46.59","51.08","0","","25","Hate speech therefore poses a challenge for modern liberal societies,","false",[["0.37200000000000005","0",["IH=>I"],"which"],["78.856","90",["Z=>S"],"societies"]]]],["20.1_1",["136696150018-61fd-d4a2-58fb-81f7-29a81769930512995#20.1#10050174#0#0##","36.2","41.1","0","","25","which are committed to both freedom","false",[["17.94","19.9",["IH=>I"],"equality"]]]],["20.1_2",["136696150018-08c5-9e84-3f2a-e06a-95691769930522595#20.1#10050174#0#0##","55.71","50.1","0","","25","which are committed to both freedom","false",[["5.682","0",["S=>SH"],"expression"]]]],["21.1_1",["136696150018-6fc4-b855-dc38-8f0a-ec771769930534704#21.1#10050174#0#0##","92.85","61.92","0","","25","of expression and social equality.","false"]],["22.1_1",["136696150018-740a-fb0d-1d1e-c64f-44951769930540635#22.1#10050174#0#0##","90","40.2","0","","25","Thus,","false",[["11.958","90",["DH=>D"],"Thus"]]]],["23.1_1",["136696150018-4013-f685-f0d0-ed21-92ea1769930550716#23.1#10050174#0#0##","54.92","46.53","0","","25","there is an ongoing debate in those societies over whether","false",[["77.656","90",["Z=>S"],"is"],["12.696","90",["DH=>D","Z=>S"],"those"],["2.622","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"societies"]]]],["24.1_1",["136696150018-bb55-b64c-605b-6112-438c1769930560356#24.1#10050174#0#0##","74.63","68.67","0","","25","and how hate speech should be regulated or censored.","false"]],["25.1_1",["136696150018-75d6-0ff9-754b-e0bd-28761769930574373#25.1#10050174#0#0##","65.45","67.24","0","","25","The traditional liberal position regarding hate","false",[["0.9480000000000001","0",["DH=>D"],"The"],["73.936","82.42",["IH=>I"],"it"]]]],["26.1_1",["136696150018-d7b7-1e14-6415-fbd3-4e8f1769930584863#26.1#10050174#0#0##","29.39","43.95","0","","25","speech is to permit it under the auspices of freedom of expression.","false",[["0.12","90",["I=>IH"],"speech"],["78.152","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"],["73.32000000000001","71.65",["DH=>D","AE=>A"],"that"],["0.12","0",["AE=>A"],"acknowledge"],["16.740000000000002","7.9",["DH=>D","Z=>S"],"those"]]]],["27.1_1",["136696150018-48bd-240d-d692-635f-4ac51769930593816#27.1#10050174#0#0##","59.62","47.58","0","","25","Although those who take that position acknowledge","false",[["76.976","90",["DH=>D"],"Although"],["11.394","90",["DH=>D"],"those"],["22.572000000000003","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["75.83200000000001","90",["AE=>A"],"acknowledge"],["14.736000000000002","14.56",["E+I=>A"],"take"]]]],["28.1_1",["136696150018-4523-4748-fe28-fa3d-ed9d1769930601910#28.1#10050174#0#0##","7.28","27.76","0","","25","the odious nature of the messages of hate speech,","false",[["73.18400000000001","81.48",["IH=>I"],"is"],["0.756","0",["ER=>I R"],"nature"],["62.912000000000006","58.64",["O=>U","D=>JH"],"odious"],["0.18000000000000002","0",["S=>SH","E+I=>A"],"state"]]]],["28.1_2",["136696150018-e601-f9a9-836a-347c-46dd1769930609240#28.1#10050174#0#0##","51","20.6","0","","25","the odious nature of the messages of hate speech,","false",[["7.53","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["38.264","90",["Z=>S"],"messages"]]]],["29.1_1",["136696150018-b240-113e-8e08-2f05-40701769930617101#29.1#10050174#0#0##","60.42","51.45","0","","25","they maintain that state censorship is a cure","false",[["0.15000000000000002","90",["DH=>D"],"they"],["78.304","87.88",["Z=>S"],"is"]]]],["30.1_1",["136696150018-fba9-a31d-7cd9-5200-0dd31769930628144#30.1#10050174#0#0##","66.18","53.54","0","","25","that causes more harm than the disease of bigoted expression.","false",[["47.592000000000006","90",["Z=>S","Z=>S"],"causes"],["77.512","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["78.856","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S","Z=>S"],"disease"]]]],["31.1_1",["136696150018-e3fb-f7d9-1aa4-ed5b-a13b1769930637222#31.1#10050174#0#0##","53.77","51.54","0","","25","They fear that a principle of censorship will lead to","false",[["0.126","0",["U=>O"],"to"],["46","90",["EH=>I"],"lead"]]]],["32.1_1",["136696150018-9310-9913-402a-97c6-26d11769930646373#32.1#10050174#0#0##","93.17","78.43","0","","25","the suppression of other unpopular but nevertheless legitimate expression,","false"]],["33.1_1",["136696150018-da39-1aa1-cb1d-50bd-24b91769930653901#33.1#10050174#0#0##","71.74","27.04","0","","25","perhaps even of the criticism of government,","false",[["8.892000000000001","90",["AE=>A"],"perhaps"],["66.016","90",["Z=>S"],"criticism"],["3.5700000000000003","90",["AH=>O","ER=>I R"],"government"]]]],["34.1_1",["136696150018-7bfc-26da-5ef9-eff6-984d1769930662847#34.1#10050174#0#0##","53.55","34.41","0","","25","which is vital to the political health of liberal democracy.","false",[["3.0780000000000003","0",["DH=>D","E+I=>A"],"They"],["79.11200000000001","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["78.36000000000001","90",["TH=>T"],"health"]]]],["35.1_1",["136696150018-7bc4-2341-007e-6a7b-d6881769930671617#35.1#10050174#0#0##","51.08","58.02","0","","25","They argue that the best way to counter hate speech is to","false",[["18.330000000000002","10.55",["DH=>D","E+I=>A"],"They"],["8.958","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["62.048","90",["U=>O"],"to"],["62.728","68.41",["IH=>I"],"its"],["73.776","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"]]]],["36.1_1",["136696150018-0672-da67-38e9-e60c-246b1769930679800#36.1#10050174#0#0##","76.97","34.02","0","","25","demonstrate its falsity in the open marketplace of ideas.","false",[["0.31200000000000006","90",["I=>IH"],"falsity"],["78.368","90",["IH=>I"],"in"],["23.502000000000002","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["0.30600000000000005","90",["AH=>O"],"of"]]]],["37.1_1",["136696150018-d7ed-3bde-bc51-d818-10671769930691790#37.1#10050174#0#0##","50.23","32.41","0","","25","Proponents of censorship typically argue that the traditional liberal position wrongly assumes the social","false",[["5.142","0",["U=>O"],"to"],["0.12","0",["IH=>I","EH=>I"],"neglects"],["47.048","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["44.544000000000004","45.68",["DH=>D"],"the"],["0.96","90",["IH=>I","SH=>S"],"traditional"]]]],["38.1_1",["136696150018-3ac8-c8a4-3488-2af7-1dc01769930706946#38.1#10050174#0#0##","44.97","47.66","0","","25","equality of persons and groups in society and neglects the fact that there are marginalized groups who are especially vulnerable to the evils of hate speech.","false",[["16.872","90",["V=>B"],"of"],["4.038","0",["DH=>D"],"that"],["78.82400000000001","90",["AE=>A"],"fact"],["72.49600000000001","80.62",["DH=>D"],"they"],["77.608","90",["Z=>S"],"marginalized"],["0.12","0",["D=>JH"],"and"],["53.528","56.91",["IH=>I"],"in"],["62.488","90",["V=>B"],"vulnerable"],["36.432","35.54",["Z=>S"],"evils"]]]],["39.1_1",["136696150018-7a48-35da-c1ad-4e6b-e9c61769930714023#39.1#10050174#0#0##","35.73","57.35","0","","25","Hate speech, they argue,","false"]],["39.1_2",["136696150018-a87f-83df-6b42-c0fc-37581769930719311#39.1#10050174#0#0##","59.4","54.9","0","","25","Hate speech, they argue,","false"]],["40.1_1",["136696150018-27e2-8bf5-d644-76fe-180c1769930726884#40.1#10050174#0#0##","73.34","35.64","0","","25","is not merely the expression of ideas,","false",[["1.074","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["23.958000000000002","90",["V=>B"],"of"]]]],["41.1_1",["136696150018-0f79-e51f-b747-eee2-c22c1769930733446#41.1#10050174#0#0##","50.92","73.75","0","","25","but rather it is an effective","false",[["74.584","90",["DH=>D"],"rather"],["59.92000000000001","90",["Z=>S"],"is"]]]],["42.1_1",["136696150018-5aa6-6d42-af8b-a921-c2561769930741262#42.1#10050174#0#0##","71.46","56.4","0","","25","means of socially subordinating its victims.","false",[["1.026","0",["AE=>A"],"at"],["10.554000000000002","90",["E+I=>A"],"subordinating"]]]],["43.1_1",["136696150018-3e72-8b7d-54c0-a300-044b1769930748744#43.1#10050174#0#0##","92.42","68.83","0","","25","When aimed at historically oppressed minorities,","false",[["47.61600000000001","90",["Z=>S"],"minorities"]]]],["44.1_1",["136696150018-99a2-42f7-0bd7-b424-14071769930756444#44.1#10050174#0#0##","55.26","78.31","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false"]],["45.1_1",["136696150018-41ff-3b06-43be-75bf-91e81769930765557#45.1#10050174#0#0##","76.13","68.16","0","","25","also perpetuates their oppression by causing the victims,","false",[["78.608","88.26",["AE=>A"],"at"],["0.12","0",["D=>JH"],"and"],["70.968","90",["Z=>S"],"causing"],["78.632","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["67.904","90",["V=>B","Z=>S"],"victims"]]]],["46.1_1",["136696150018-1aff-20ba-e967-d0ae-72f21769930773320#46.1#10050174#0#0##","31.73","55.62","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large","false",[["77.75200000000001","87.19",["AE=>A"],"act"]]]]]}