{"speech_score":["1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1"],"media_score":[["0.1_1",["136705140009-f0ba-aa64-4790-d031-00d61769766414578#0.1#10050174#0#0##","64.75","69.03","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that denigrates a person or persons","false",[["1.002","0",["I=>IH"],"speech"]]]],["1.1_1",["136705140009-cb1c-8376-fbe8-e5d2-58691769766463077#1.1#10050174#0#0##","72.36","85.19","0","","25","on the basis of (alleged) membership in a social group identified by attributes such as race,","false"]],["2.1_1",["136705140009-6830-12df-3f6d-a8c7-645d1769766501945#2.1#10050174#0#0##","96.1","94.94","0","","25","ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age,","false"]],["3.1_1",["136705140009-bfe6-c7e6-2949-54e6-f1a41769766543612#3.1#10050174#0#0##","93.57","78.12","0","","25","physical or mental disability and others.","false"]],["4.1_1",["136705140009-63e4-214b-bd0a-23d8-aa4d1769766572822#4.1#10050174#0#0##","75.48","78.52","0","","25","Typical hate speech involves epithets and slurs,","false",[["9.75","6.25",["DH=>D"],"that"]]]],["5.1_1",["136705140009-ebc1-b075-b1e6-c433-85411769766601950#5.1#10050174#0#0##","94.56","83.16","0","","25","statements that promote malicious stereotypes","false",[["32.96","90",["DH=>D"],"that"]]]],["6.1_1",["136705140009-f4b5-a127-abce-0844-9e2b1769766642914#6.1#10050174#0#0##","84","79.09","0","","25","and speech intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false"]],["7.1_1",["136705140009-e402-a4b0-2b84-6c4d-26081769766676112#7.1#10050174#0#0##","80.48","91.58","0","","25","Hate speech can also include nonverbal depictions and symbols.","false",[["71.288","90",["Z=>S"],"symbols"]]]],["8.1_1",["136705140009-af81-5c08-cbf9-54bd-a4671769766682944#8.1#10050174#0#0##","1.34","7.97","0","","25","For example,","false",[["15.642","16.07",["AE=>A"],"battle"]]]],["8.1_2",["136705140009-2408-3910-361f-be08-63da1769766688701#8.1#10050174#0#0##","90","26.88","0","","25","For example,","false",[["77.32000000000001","86.65",["D=>JH"],"and"]]]],["9.1_1",["136705140009-cf27-355f-a8fe-322a-87401769766720282#9.1#10050174#0#0##","73.48","93.86","0","","25","the Nazi swastika and the Confederate battle flag (of the Confederate","false"]],["10.1_1",["136705140009-7d15-cd53-6eca-167e-45d91769766748035#10.1#10050174#0#0##","78.64","96.21","0","","25","States of America) have been considered hate speech by a variety of people and groups.","false"]],["11.1_1",["136705140009-779d-4cb3-7303-47f5-1fcd1769766756611#11.1#10050174#0#0##","64.99","74.27","0","","25","Critics of hate speech argue not only","false"]],["12.1_1",["136705140009-8f3d-6f52-bda4-a6a9-afea1769766765643#12.1#10050174#0#0##","46.73","64.43","0","","25","that it causes psychological harm to its victims,","false"]],["13.1_1",["136705140009-8f37-4340-ab35-417e-1a361769766773780#13.1#10050174#0#0##","92.43","58.3","0","","25","and physical harm when it incites violence,","false"]],["14.1_1",["136705140009-bda3-cf68-4f45-eb66-05771769766781090#14.1#10050174#0#0##","91.6","75.89","0","","25","but also that it undermines","false"]],["15.1_1",["136705140009-6c44-1d71-bfea-2e89-a88f1769766789232#15.1#10050174#0#0##","43.45","21.42","0","","25","the social equality of its victims.","false"]],["16.1_1",["136705140009-351b-c0bf-7f76-0277-c3c01769766797673#16.1#10050174#0#0##","71.3","63.2","0","","25","That is particularly true, they claim,","false"]],["17.1_1",["136705140009-c3f3-7f69-ea67-2bf7-59ab1769766806454#17.1#10050174#0#0##","66.02","62.93","0","","25","because the social groups that are commonly the targets of","false"]],["18.1_1",["136705140009-2355-61bd-d0a2-2080-b8351769766816799#18.1#10050174#0#0##","77.05","45.6","0","","25","hate speech have historically suffered from social marginalization and oppression.","false"]],["19.1_1",["136705140009-c68f-4af8-8fb0-bad9-e5681769766827878#19.1#10050174#0#0##","78.42","48.8","0","","25","Hate speech therefore poses a challenge for modern liberal societies,","false"]],["20.1_1",["136705140009-774c-7622-42f5-3743-79321769766835329#20.1#10050174#0#0##","50.65","45.5","0","","25","which are committed to both freedom","false",[["0.13799999999999998","0",["TH=>T"],"both"]]]],["21.1_1",["136705140009-a64c-4df4-b73f-51f6-e1851769766843771#21.1#10050174#0#0##","91.55","62.58","0","","25","of expression and social equality.","false",[["42.136","90",["IH=>I"],"equality"]]]],["22.1_1",["136705140009-f600-c2aa-471a-194f-64ec1769766849524#22.1#10050174#0#0##","96.17","96.17","0","","25","Thus,","false"]],["23.1_1",["136705140009-d4af-c7ab-8dd6-71df-88991769766888161#23.1#10050174#0#0##","40.1","55.53","0","","25","there is an ongoing debate in those societies over whether","false"]],["24.1_1",["136705140009-0889-610c-1fcb-b6a5-e82b1769766896701#24.1#10050174#0#0##","91.99","59.3","0","","25","and how hate speech should be regulated or censored.","false",[["79.21600000000001","90",["SH=>S"],"should"]]]],["25.1_1",["136705140009-c3bc-6bb4-41a1-0825-48201769766905140#25.1#10050174#0#0##","51.16","29.77","0","","25","The traditional liberal position regarding hate","false"]],["26.1_1",["136705140009-0074-9072-0b10-070c-1cc31769766915936#26.1#10050174#0#0##","76.85","55.84","0","","25","speech is to permit it under the auspices of freedom of expression.","false"]],["27.1_1",["136705140009-c52f-4b18-c287-a618-cb931769766924481#27.1#10050174#0#0##","37.32","42.85","0","","25","Although those who take that position acknowledge","false"]],["28.1_1",["136705140009-5217-66e8-c273-4822-5b511769766932871#28.1#10050174#0#0##","63.86","67","0","","25","the odious nature of the messages of hate speech,","false"]],["29.1_1",["136705140009-a6ba-5d58-22ef-c5e3-defe1769766941833#29.1#10050174#0#0##","46.81","52.19","0","","25","they maintain that state censorship is a cure","false"]],["30.1_1",["136705140009-7183-ed8b-bf6b-5cf8-3be41769766951008#30.1#10050174#0#0##","16.35","33.33","0","","25","that causes more harm than the disease of bigoted expression.","false"]],["30.1_2",["136705140009-7f9e-7ae6-3fe7-f6c1-838e1769766960093#30.1#10050174#0#0##","31.49","53.11","0","","25","that causes more harm than the disease of bigoted expression.","false"]],["30.1_3",["136705140009-6586-2bb3-776f-ba84-67201769766994544#30.1#10050174#0#0##","69.52","87.82","0","","25","that causes more harm than the disease of bigoted expression.","false"]],["31.1_1",["136705140009-2507-f24c-5959-03af-f4301769767004111#31.1#10050174#0#0##","38.88","63.27","0","","25","They fear that a principle of censorship will lead to","false"]],["31.1_2",["136705140009-d81a-19d9-2765-4564-44821769767027293#31.1#10050174#0#0##","65.86","41.92","0","","25","They fear that a principle of censorship will lead to","false"]],["32.1_1",["136705140009-be1c-4024-9363-794f-fe1b1769767038280#32.1#10050174#0#0##","64.62","50.02","0","","25","the suppression of other unpopular but nevertheless legitimate expression,","false"]],["33.1_1",["136705140009-20ec-252f-9c3d-30e2-22f11769767046431#33.1#10050174#0#0##","68.13","60.64","0","","25","perhaps even of the criticism of government,","false"]],["34.1_1",["136705140009-eb7a-456e-d042-2584-d5ec1769767055034#34.1#10050174#0#0##","77.6","45.59","0","","25","which is vital to the political health of liberal democracy.","false"]],["35.1_1",["136705140009-6c8a-cced-1cdf-00f5-32251769767130435#35.1#10050174#0#0##","37.6","62.05","0","","25","They argue that the best way to counter hate speech is to","false",[["73.704","82.13",["DH=>D"],"that"],["73.65599999999999","82.07",["E+I=>A"],"hate"],["0.21000000000000002","0",["DH=>D","E+I=>A"],"They"],["78.67200000000001","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"]]]],["35.1_2",["136705140009-3ea8-1540-f7ca-8622-b06f1769767073645#35.1#10050174#0#0##","36.33","55.92","0","","25","They argue that the best way to counter hate speech is to","false"]],["35.1_3",["136705140009-0a1d-fc44-55fb-9eb2-ca4a1769767082570#35.1#10050174#0#0##","29.28","54.51","0","","25","They argue that the best way to counter hate speech is to","false"]],["36.1_1",["136705140009-1302-5fc9-4f8f-d5b8-18fc1769767140475#36.1#10050174#0#0##","77.36","47.6","0","","25","demonstrate its falsity in the open marketplace of ideas.","false",[["66.632","90",["F=>P"],"falsity"],["71.44","90",["AH=>O"],"of"],["64.688","70.86",["IH=>I"],"in"],["1.4880000000000002","0",["DH=>D"],"that"]]]],["37.1_1",["136705140009-dcab-08de-f5eb-568e-71e51769767153249#37.1#10050174#0#0##","39.01","48.6","0","","25","Proponents of censorship typically argue that the traditional liberal position wrongly assumes the social","false",[["0.132","0",["I=>IH"],"equality"],["56.768","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["0.144","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"typically"],["64.296","90",["SH=>S"],"traditional"],["22.536","27.56",["IH=>I"],"liberal"],["21.018","15.03",["O=>U","A+I=>IH","I=>IH"],"society"],["62.38400000000001","90",["S=>SH","U=>O"],"assumes"]]]],["38.1_1",["136705140009-f98f-4a8a-1410-35d6-6da11769767170207#38.1#10050174#0#0##","26.56","36.38","0","","25","equality of persons and groups in society and neglects the fact that there are marginalized groups who are especially vulnerable to the evils of hate speech.","false",[["0.12","0",["I=>IH"],"equality"],["77.888","90",["AH=>O"],"of"],["73.992","90",["IH=>I"],"society"],["76.13600000000001","90",["U=>O"],"groups"],["7.374","2.29",["DH=>D"],"that"],["0.31800000000000006","0",["DH=>D"],"they"],["73.096","81.37",["E+I=>A"],"hate"],["0.12","90",["Z=>S"],"marginalized"],["0.12","0",["I=>IH"],"especially"],["16.806","18.01",["AA=>U"],"are"],["1.494","0",["Z=>S"],"evils"],["1.8840000000000001","0",["IH=>I"],"in"]]]],["38.1_2",["136705140009-242e-1ae0-9c5f-3d36-da081769767188772#38.1#10050174#0#0##","45.45","42.33","0","","25","equality of persons and groups in society and neglects the fact that there are marginalized groups who are especially vulnerable to the evils of hate speech.","false",[["19.374000000000002","90",["I=>IH"],"equality"],["70.62400000000001","90",["U=>O"],"groups"],["77.24000000000001","86.55",["V=>B"],"of"],["8.700000000000001","90",["IH=>I"],"in"],["76.65599999999999","90",["IH=>I"],"society"],["77.03200000000001","86.29",["DH=>D"],"that"],["49.984","52.48",["DH=>D"],"they"],["78.424","78.03",["F=>P","AE=>A"],"fact"],["1.212","0",["Z=>S"],"marginalized"],["0.48","90",["V=>B","Z=>S"],"evils"]]]],["38.1_3",["136705140009-d2b1-e1ed-364f-dbca-b1eb1769767227298#38.1#10050174#0#0##","71.53","73","0","","25","equality of persons and groups in society and neglects the fact that there are marginalized groups who are especially vulnerable to the evils of hate speech.","false",[["45.72","90",["IH=>I"],"equality"],["76.23200000000001","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["1.62","90",["DH=>D"],"there"]]]],["39.1_1",["136705140009-94f8-2d56-69ac-54f5-ff801769767236691#39.1#10050174#0#0##","62.83","45","0","","25","Hate speech, they argue,","false",[["0.16200000000000003","0",["AA=>U"],"not"],["0.12","90",["I=>IH"],"speech"],["0.144","0",["AH=>O","V=>B"],"of"]]]],["40.1_1",["136705140009-6b2a-dfbc-3868-91fc-63871769767244673#40.1#10050174#0#0##","92.15","57.1","0","","25","is not merely the expression of ideas,","false",[["23.76","90",["IH=>I"],"is"]]]],["41.1_1",["136705140009-6900-c36a-29bc-5282-0d6b1769767252046#41.1#10050174#0#0##","43.48","49.73","0","","25","but rather it is an effective","false",[["0.16200000000000003","90",["AE=>A","ER=>I R"],"rather"],["75.536","90",["Z=>S"],"is"],["16.146","16.91",["AE=>A"],"an"],["6.534000000000001","0.89",["F=>P"],"effective"]]]],["42.1_1",["136705140009-3330-ecd8-88b4-27d8-3d4a1769767260540#42.1#10050174#0#0##","39.03","33.12","0","","25","means of socially subordinating its victims.","false",[["5.364000000000001","90",["IH=>I"],"its"],["5.49","90",["IH=>I"],"subordinating"]]]],["43.1_1",["136705140009-f7a2-5a6f-5780-67fd-fba81769767269762#43.1#10050174#0#0##","51.28","53.26","0","","25","When aimed at historically oppressed minorities,","false",[["58.168","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"historically"],["78.57600000000001","88.22",["AE=>A"],"at"]]]],["44.1_1",["136705140009-b7d3-bad6-6e5b-58c0-c2f51769767278089#44.1#10050174#0#0##","72.54","49.86","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false",[["0.6360000000000001","0",["AA=>U"],"not"],["0.18600000000000003","90",["I=>IH"],"speech"],["78.392","90",["Z=>S"],"is"],["34.368","90",["AH=>O"],"insulting"]]]],["45.1_1",["136705140009-f602-9f87-aaaf-eb21-2c8f1769767287469#45.1#10050174#0#0##","28.58","31.18","0","","25","also perpetuates their oppression by causing the victims,","false",[["0.132","0",["S=>SH","S=>SH","A+I=>IH","I=>IH"],"society"],["69.488","90",["Z=>S","IH=>I"],"causing"],["71.8","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["8.802","90",["V=>B","Z=>S"],"victims"]]]],["46.1_1",["136705140009-57ff-a607-5889-2312-c4391769767296000#46.1#10050174#0#0##","14.24","61.58","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large","false",[["78.26400000000001","90",["IH=>I"],"society"]]]],["46.1_2",["136705140009-3962-a6df-1834-6800-1d531769767337544#46.1#10050174#0#0##","53.95","71.83","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large","false",[["0.27599999999999997","0",["AE=>A"],"at"]]]],["47.1_1",["136705140009-7e3e-b072-e962-81b9-8c4f1769767361008#47.1#10050174#0#0##","97.31","76.53","0","","25","to internalize the hateful messages and act accordingly.","false",[["0.12","0",["U=>O"],"to"]]]],["48.1_1",["136705140009-2df6-bb8c-22d7-1bdb-fd9e1769767379971#48.1#10050174#0#0##","94.51","72.2","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot","false"]],["49.1_1",["136705140009-da93-444e-506c-331f-ce751769767403861#49.1#10050174#0#0##","70.38","37.91","0","","25","enter the \"open marketplace of ideas\"","false",[["0.192","90",["ER=>I R"],"enter"]]]],["50.1_1",["136705140009-bfb8-ec76-044d-852e-c0ae1769767434860#50.1#10050174#0#0##","47.57","33.29","0","","25","as equal participants to defend themselves, because hate speech,","false",[["7.902","3.17",["AE=>A"],"as"]]]],["51.1_1",["136705140009-1747-cd07-66a2-5486-3e211769767466353#51.1#10050174#0#0##","51.02","47.13","0","","25","in conjunction with a broader system of inequality","false",[["6.15","90",["DH=>D"],"with"],["68.23200000000001","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"inequality"]]]],["52.1_1",["136705140009-7e8b-ba87-850a-1009-82361769767489696#52.1#10050174#0#0##","73.99","72.34","0","","25","and unjust discrimination that burdens the victims,","false",[["78.584","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["75.36","90",["DH=>D"],"the"]]]],["53.1_1",["136705140009-220f-8085-4fca-e0f7-67d61769767508936#53.1#10050174#0#0##","90.79","83.65","0","","25","effectively silences them.","false",[["79.128","90",["Z=>S"],"silences"]]]],["54.1_1",["136705140009-bf7f-feab-33f4-8e10-7fd81769767531156#54.1#10050174#0#0##","48.6","69.69","0","","25","The court system of the United States has,","false",[["4.806000000000001","90",["V=>B"],"of"]]]],["55.1_1",["136705140009-42b9-d6d4-9767-818e-dfc41769767555227#55.1#10050174#0#0##","41.3","36.59","0","","25","on the basis of the First Amendment","false"]],["56.1_1",["136705140009-3f47-b0da-3030-de51-67961769767607335#56.1#10050174#0#0##","44.44","23","0","","25","and its principle of freedom of speech,","false",[["0.8580000000000001","0",["IH=>I","S=>SH"],"its"]]]]]}