{"speech_score":["1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","0","","","","","","","","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1"],"media_score":[["0.1_1",["107820140072-9614-0030-e54f-78ed-72d21773145108874#0.1#10050174#0#0##","9","27.13","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that denigrates a person or persons","false"]],["0.1_2",["107820140072-0db5-c1d4-e562-0493-e4841773068056587#0.1#10050174#0#0##","9","0.58","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that denigrates a person or persons","false"]],["0.1_3",["107820140072-58f4-1200-9601-ea17-7e9c1773145222614#0.1#10050174#0#0##","21.29","52.73","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that denigrates a person or persons","false"]],["0.1_4",["107820140072-042a-97a4-c797-be08-7dd81773145238519#0.1#10050174#0#0##","6.95","30.69","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that denigrates a person or persons","false"]],["0.1_5",["107820140072-d65b-7edc-17bb-0546-44411773145249615#0.1#10050174#0#0##","9.72","7.72","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that denigrates a person or persons","false",[["0.12","0",["U=>O"],"group"]]]],["1.1_1",["107820140072-bba9-de63-1ba6-29ef-fe901773145276063#1.1#10050174#0#0##","6.15","8.48","0","","25","on the basis of (alleged) membership in a social group identified by attributes such as race,","false"]],["1.1_2",["107820140072-f497-2193-1f50-dc5c-0c8a1773145287320#1.1#10050174#0#0##","29.13","36.21","0","","25","on the basis of (alleged) membership in a social group identified by attributes such as race,","false"]],["1.1_3",["107820140072-ee9b-c2a0-b05a-8675-61da1773145310515#1.1#10050174#0#0##","36.81","39.58","0","","25","on the basis of (alleged) membership in a social group identified by attributes such as race,","false"]],["2.1_1",["107820140072-9b03-5fde-2a81-8488-87b61773145369990#2.1#10050174#0#0##","50.4","17.71","0","","25","ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age,","false",[["1.26","90",["EH=>I"],"orientation"]]]],["3.1_1",["107820140072-11b4-77a6-2ab1-29f9-f6161773145377700#3.1#10050174#0#0##","28.11","26.09","0","","25","physical or mental disability and others.","false"]],["3.1_2",["107820140072-4431-9adb-42b0-2188-43461773145386193#3.1#10050174#0#0##","70.33","68.85","0","","25","physical or mental disability and others.","false"]],["4.1_1",["107820140072-2ead-bba3-941b-323c-55f81773145395635#4.1#10050174#0#0##","72.66","50.61","0","","25","Typical hate speech involves epithets and slurs,","false"]],["5.1_1",["107820140072-67ea-3a65-6acd-abb4-ed531773145407736#5.1#10050174#0#0##","0","0.16","0","","25","statements that promote malicious stereotypes","false"]],["5.1_2",["107820140072-fe19-5e71-d8c4-1df9-4a6c1773145414968#5.1#10050174#0#0##","25.2","13.13","0","","25","statements that promote malicious stereotypes","false",[["2.58","90",["IH=>I"],"malicious"]]]],["5.1_3",["107820140072-694f-e3b7-1d8d-9172-3f681773145428736#5.1#10050174#0#0##","25.2","29.44","0","","25","statements that promote malicious stereotypes","false"]],["6.1_1",["107820140072-4070-fcad-ccec-53a3-8b851773145439712#6.1#10050174#0#0##","23.56","10.75","0","","25","and speech intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false"]],["6.1_2",["107820140072-f03a-c2a1-bc5c-ab63-f0ba1773145450614#6.1#10050174#0#0##","80.01","47.78","0","","25","and speech intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false",[["77.83200000000001","90",["V=>B"],"violence"]]]],["7.1_1",["107820140072-d192-c320-7b0c-6f24-69a31773145460991#7.1#10050174#0#0##","42.44","57.78","0","","25","Hate speech can also include nonverbal depictions and symbols.","false",[["16.644000000000002","17.74",["AE=>A"],"can"]]]],["8.1_1",["107820140072-0676-02bb-51c4-4832-1aa71773145466554#8.1#10050174#0#0##","90","28.89","0","","25","For example,","false"]],["9.1_1",["107820140072-8878-984f-d32f-886d-e67a1773145475595#9.1#10050174#0#0##","39.84","40.2","0","","25","the Nazi swastika and the Confederate battle flag (of the Confederate","false"]],["10.1_1",["107820140072-c5c7-e895-b4b1-d893-3a631773145488003#10.1#10050174#0#0##","29.55","38.49","0","","25","States of America) have been considered hate speech by a variety of people and groups.","false"]],["10.1_2",["107820140072-32be-9cad-7305-e077-e4cd1773145500796#10.1#10050174#0#0##","40.01","28.59","0","","25","States of America) have been considered hate speech by a variety of people and groups.","false"]],["11.1_1",["107820140072-1674-df0d-cee2-d32e-3fb81773145508701#11.1#10050174#0#0##","52.23","67.41","0","","25","Critics of hate speech argue not only","false",[["68.12","75.15",["IH=>I"],"its"]]]],["12.1_1",["107820140072-2993-4063-3908-4e59-00031773145519851#12.1#10050174#0#0##","63.48","80.71","0","","25","that it causes psychological harm to its victims,","false",[["77.69600000000001","90",["U=>O"],"to"]]]],["13.1_1",["107820140072-78fd-41aa-9127-373c-8e5a1773145549452#13.1#10050174#0#0##","95.8","90.32","0","","25","and physical harm when it incites violence,","false"]],["14.1_1",["107820140072-a371-71d8-1196-8a80-602f1773145555739#14.1#10050174#0#0##","66.44","54.92","0","","25","but also that it undermines","false"]],["15.1_1",["107820140072-45e0-1c18-169a-ad21-f5051773145562779#15.1#10050174#0#0##","92.09","43.97","0","","25","the social equality of its victims.","false"]],["16.1_1",["107820140072-87ae-fb4b-d626-16a7-609f1773145569867#16.1#10050174#0#0##","34.2","28.84","0","","25","That is particularly true, they claim,","false"]],["17.1_1",["107820140072-2da1-94d2-5260-4355-7e2a1773145582576#17.1#10050174#0#0##","54.85","51.34","0","","25","because the social groups that are commonly the targets of","false"]],["18.1_1",["107820140072-2527-d061-4805-fe6d-8aa01773145655324#18.1#10050174#0#0##","25.2","11.95","0","","25","hate speech have historically suffered from social marginalization and oppression.","false"]],["18.1_2",["107820140072-500a-7489-e774-99a0-693a1773145666272#18.1#10050174#0#0##","66.15","45.33","0","","25","hate speech have historically suffered from social marginalization and oppression.","false"]],["19.1_1",["107820140072-1278-5e97-ede3-0a8f-25351773145676442#19.1#10050174#0#0##","54.21","47.76","0","","25","Hate speech therefore poses a challenge for modern liberal societies,","false"]],["20.1_1",["107820140072-351d-a83d-5bea-d1a3-9fb41773145684060#20.1#10050174#0#0##","69","31.81","0","","25","which are committed to both freedom","false"]],["21.1_1",["107820140072-091c-41ce-87d8-ad7f-61f91773145691167#21.1#10050174#0#0##","44.08","41.12","0","","25","of expression and social equality.","false"]],["22.1_1",["107820140072-4cc5-864d-4dad-7168-d8301773145696774#22.1#10050174#0#0##","90","3.59","0","","25","Thus,","false",[["3.5880000000000005","90",["DH=>D"],"Thus"]]]],["23.1_1",["107820140072-92c3-8177-ca1f-3a16-c26e1773145798550#23.1#10050174#0#0##","48.49","40.53","0","","25","there is an ongoing debate in those societies over whether","false"]],["24.1_1",["107820140072-15af-7c78-2c7c-6613-cf531773145807254#24.1#10050174#0#0##","76.5","38.18","0","","25","and how hate speech should be regulated or censored.","false",[["3.426","0",["DH=>D"],"The"]]]],["25.1_1",["107820140072-aa89-170d-ef62-8622-fef11773145819349#25.1#10050174#0#0##","34.2","39.2","0","","25","The traditional liberal position regarding hate","false"]],["26.1_1",["107820140072-b0b9-da37-0c3c-b066-8fa91773145834055#26.1#10050174#0#0##","4.2","1.54","0","","25","speech is to permit it under the auspices of freedom of expression.","false",[["1.8239999999999998","0",["E+I=>A"],"take"]]]],["26.1_2",["107820140072-d67e-73ea-fac3-10a2-05fb1773145843348#26.1#10050174#0#0##","1.77","14.22","0","","25","speech is to permit it under the auspices of freedom of expression.","false",[["0.126","0",["DH=>D","AE=>A"],"that"]]]],["26.1_3",["107820140072-5b21-b169-649d-9520-99ec1773145867311#26.1#10050174#0#0##","28.36","38.67","0","","25","speech is to permit it under the auspices of freedom of expression.","false"]],["26.1_4",["107820140072-80c2-7775-d14c-07a6-d1171773145880698#26.1#10050174#0#0##","19.92","41.34","0","","25","speech is to permit it under the auspices of freedom of expression.","false"]],["26.1_5",["107820140072-7c52-47b2-3148-2dd5-fe831773145892479#26.1#10050174#0#0##","50.69","49.19","0","","25","speech is to permit it under the auspices of freedom of expression.","false"]],["27.1_1",["107820140072-bdc6-7dba-cf0f-dba5-268b1773145901400#27.1#10050174#0#0##","45.3","14.85","0","","25","Although those who take that position acknowledge","false"]],["28.1_1",["107820140072-98e6-7c08-a2c3-2e0c-35c01773145916160#28.1#10050174#0#0##","21","15.91","0","","25","the odious nature of the messages of hate speech,","false"]],["28.1_2",["107820140072-f56b-5f68-8273-971f-69501773145924980#28.1#10050174#0#0##","40.61","40.59","0","","25","the odious nature of the messages of hate speech,","false"]],["29.1_1",["107820140072-83a2-3449-3311-1122-74131773145932769#29.1#10050174#0#0##","74.02","41.25","0","","25","they maintain that state censorship is a cure","false"]],["30.1_1",["107820140072-ea0a-8028-2d0e-2da8-bbca1773145942648#30.1#10050174#0#0##","30.83","47.53","0","","25","that causes more harm than the disease of bigoted expression.","false"]],["31.1_1",["107820140072-764b-e28e-c2fe-a441-5dca1773145952648#31.1#10050174#0#0##","53.55","52.55","0","","25","They fear that a principle of censorship will lead to","false"]],["32.1_1",["107820140072-548c-ffdb-b7cb-3110-bf7f1773145962999#32.1#10050174#0#0##","63.24","35.07","0","","25","the suppression of other unpopular but nevertheless legitimate expression,","false"]],["33.1_1",["107820140072-7802-509a-62b3-8f5e-10b41773145972073#33.1#10050174#0#0##","72.8","52.94","0","","25","perhaps even of the criticism of government,","false"]],["34.1_1",["107820140072-098a-e053-a9e8-cd18-53691773145993028#34.1#10050174#0#0##","13.34","52.77","0","","25","which is vital to the political health of liberal democracy.","false"]],["42.1_1",["107820140072-79fa-0def-0b59-187a-cb681773170339636#42.1#10050174#0#0##","3.84","53.25","0","","25","means of socially subordinating its victims.","false",[["78.08","87.6",["EH=>I"],"When"],["73.888","82.36",["AE=>A"],"at"],["7.7700000000000005","2.95",["E+I=>A"],"aimed"]]]],["42.1_2",["107820140072-0b03-04b4-e826-c89f-5f5b1773170349322#42.1#10050174#0#0##","21.2","22.02","0","","25","means of socially subordinating its victims.","false",[["76.264","85.33",["AE=>A"],"at"],["10.218000000000002","7.03",["IH=>I"],"its"],["0.12","0",["S=>SH","D=>JH","IH=>I"],"subordinating"],["0.588","90",["V=>B","Z=>S"],"victims"]]]],["42.1_3",["107820140072-7247-e5b4-ac97-8338-2ba61773170359004#42.1#10050174#0#0##","34.2","25.91","0","","25","means of socially subordinating its victims.","false",[["0.06","90",["S=>SH","E+I=>A"],"subordinating"],["0.12","0",["IH=>I","IH=>I","I=>IH"],"historically"],["18.642","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"victims"]]]],["43.1_1",["107820140072-bd0f-2570-08ff-eec8-57551773170366956#43.1#10050174#0#0##","27.8","66.35","0","","25","When aimed at historically oppressed minorities,","false",[["56.84","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"historically"],["78.62400000000001","88.28",["AE=>A"],"at"],["0.12","0",["EH=>I"],"When"]]]],["44.1_1",["107820140072-df55-8581-255d-0a7d-046f1773170373826#44.1#10050174#0#0##","11.96","36.16","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false"]],["44.1_2",["107820140072-a67c-00b9-6a4c-dfb2-8fda1773170379516#44.1#10050174#0#0##","16.71","3.09","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false",[["0.12","90",["AH=>O"],"insulting"]]]],["44.1_3",["107820140072-da42-194b-1a56-4b9d-beb41773170389160#44.1#10050174#0#0##","23.18","45.28","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false",[["0.12","90",["Z=>S"],"is"],["0.132","0",["AH=>O"],"insulting"]]]],["44.1_4",["107820140072-3de6-6e3e-3063-b83f-72201773170398322#44.1#10050174#0#0##","11.53","30.55","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false"]],["44.1_5",["107820140072-ec45-cee0-71c1-5c96-078f1773170407943#44.1#10050174#0#0##","21.96","23.43","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false",[["0.06","0",["DH=>D"],"the"]]]],["44.1_6",["107820140072-8246-c49f-9f16-f511-36b01773170418085#44.1#10050174#0#0##","5.48","24.12","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false",[["2.424","0",["E+I=>A"],"hate"]]]],["44.1_7",["107820140072-e155-bf63-cac9-608a-76131773170430307#44.1#10050174#0#0##","17.38","45.84","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false"]],["45.1_1",["107820140072-7e9a-c440-6a32-b052-f8e51773170449675#45.1#10050174#0#0##","34.53","30.65","0","","25","also perpetuates their oppression by causing the victims,","false",[["61.40800000000001","66.76",["DH=>D"],"the"],["53.024","90",["DH=>D","EH=>I"],"their"],["0.12","0",["D=>JH"],"and"],["0.198","90",["V=>B"],"victims"]]]],["46.1_1",["107820140072-c077-3225-962e-183b-2f781773170457576#46.1#10050174#0#0##","50.4","15.97","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large","false",[["36.752","90",["IH=>I"],"society"]]]],["47.1_1",["107820140072-260c-4c39-8272-6458-01571773170466043#47.1#10050174#0#0##","16.97","21.29","0","","25","to internalize the hateful messages and act accordingly.","false",[["40.056000000000004","30.07",["IH=>I","ER=>I R"],"internalize"],["0.12","90",["AE=>A"],"act"]]]],["47.1_2",["107820140072-0a95-f488-444b-c56d-c14d1773170473964#47.1#10050174#0#0##","34.2","16.41","0","","25","to internalize the hateful messages and act accordingly.","false",[["0.12","90",["U=>O"],"to"],["9.312000000000001","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["0.12","0",["AE=>A"],"act"]]]],["48.1_1",["107820140072-2600-cab0-94cd-cfda-ea081773170481983#48.1#10050174#0#0##","10.8","4.7","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot","false"]],["48.1_2",["107820140072-00f0-4538-6016-fb7b-a27a1773170487439#48.1#10050174#0#0##","10.8","0.49","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot","false"]],["48.1_3",["107820140072-0f84-6317-e532-3840-b17a1773170495246#48.1#10050174#0#0##","10.8","2.37","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot","false"]],["48.1_4",["107820140072-1c04-64e4-99f7-f34f-49791773170508337#48.1#10050174#0#0##","10.8","0.79","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot","false"]],["48.1_5",["107820140072-417a-c2d5-f4b1-dfb8-5d2a1773170514469#48.1#10050174#0#0##","25.97","81.27","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot","false"]],["49.1_1",["107820140072-075b-b7fe-2bb8-df42-75141773170529525#49.1#10050174#0#0##","34.2","23.66","0","","25","enter the \"open marketplace of ideas\"","false",[["75.23200000000001","90",["V=>B"],"of"],["6.216","0.36",["Z=>S"],"as"]]]],["50.1_1",["107820140072-2ca5-fb78-8dc3-0dab-fdc81773170538826#50.1#10050174#0#0##","13","34.75","0","","25","as equal participants to defend themselves, because hate speech,","false",[["77.28800000000001","90",["Z=>S"],"as"],["13.656","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"because"]]]],["50.1_2",["107820140072-6cf8-0619-ab97-f60a-cdc01773170547253#50.1#10050174#0#0##","13","10.89","0","","25","as equal participants to defend themselves, because hate speech,","false",[["0.37200000000000005","0",["AH=>O","V=>B"],"of"],["42.864000000000004","90",["Z=>S"],"because"]]]],["50.1_3",["107820140072-8164-fb50-9a0b-8527-51b91773170564743#50.1#10050174#0#0##","23.61","45.65","0","","25","as equal participants to defend themselves, because hate speech,","false",[["0.126","0",["AO=>U","ER=>I R"],"broader"],["78.24000000000001","87.8",["Z=>S"],"as"],["8.532","4.22",["U=>O"],"to"]]]],["50.1_4",["107820140072-19e0-0ca5-ef80-6c1a-f9561773170573966#50.1#10050174#0#0##","40.32","30.84","0","","25","as equal participants to defend themselves, because hate speech,","false",[["0.12","0",["AO=>U"],"broader"],["8.076","90",["F=>P"],"defend"],["5.682","90",["DH=>D","Z=>S"],"themselves"]]]],["51.1_1",["107820140072-530c-1256-a796-494a-77201773170581234#51.1#10050174#0#0##","32.86","47.64","0","","25","in conjunction with a broader system of inequality","false",[["79.00800000000001","88.76",["DH=>D"],"the"],["0.126","0",["IH=>I"],"system"],["57.96000000000001","90",["I=>IH"],"inequality"]]]]]}