{"speech_score":["1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","","","","","","","","","","","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","0"],"media_score":[["0.1_1",["136696150013-c232-2488-b345-1d97-33451771345165665#0.1#10050271#0#0##","4.95","2.26","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that belittles a person","false"]],["0.1_2",["136696150013-6a8e-75bd-69c6-9923-d8a51771345174938#0.1#10050271#0#0##","10.8","0.69","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that belittles a person","false",[["1.2000000000000002","90",["I=>IH"],"speech"]]]],["0.1_3",["136696150013-ca86-a5b1-b552-7417-f1f71771345184599#0.1#10050271#0#0##","4.95","0.7","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that belittles a person","false",[["0.144","0",["O=>U","SH=>S"],"social"]]]],["1.1_1",["136696150013-7ac2-7676-f641-5838-463d1771345203309#1.1#10050271#0#0##","9","0.27","0","","25","or persons because they belong (even allegedly) to a certain social group.","false"]],["1.1_2",["136696150013-1b8a-0591-640f-fc94-fa3f1771345213516#1.1#10050271#0#0##","5.52","24.9","0","","25","or persons because they belong (even allegedly) to a certain social group.","false"]],["1.1_3",["136696150013-68f8-5f1c-863f-02d7-0be71771345215839#1.1#10050271#0#0##","5.52","24.9","0","","25","or persons because they belong (even allegedly) to a certain social group.","false"]],["2.1_1",["136696150013-56d4-5a14-8b66-8eaa-71571771345255810#2.1#10050271#0#0##","2.79","45.64","0","","25","That group may have attributes such as race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age, physical or mental disability and others.","false"]],["2.1_2",["136696150013-6553-320b-52f1-a0bc-cc5e1771345339386#2.1#10050271#0#0##","23.04","28","0","","25","That group may have attributes such as race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age, physical or mental disability and others.","false"]],["2.1_3",["136696150013-4366-8ded-edef-4b2c-437e1771345361924#2.1#10050271#0#0##","2.42","18.52","0","","25","That group may have attributes such as race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age, physical or mental disability and others.","false"]],["3.1_1",["136696150013-c4c1-5741-07b8-59bb-f1911771345466402#3.1#10050271#0#0##","20.68","36.57","0","","25","Typical hate speech involves labels and slurs, or statements that promote malicious stereotypes.","false"]],["3.1_2",["136696150013-62b6-e318-0108-0762-10401771345434086#3.1#10050271#0#0##","18.44","30.34","0","","25","Typical hate speech involves labels and slurs, or statements that promote malicious stereotypes.","false"]],["3.1_3",["136696150013-f54c-75e0-86ce-8e69-27511771345491273#3.1#10050271#0#0##","18.65","27.59","0","","25","Typical hate speech involves labels and slurs, or statements that promote malicious stereotypes.","false"]],["4.1_1",["136696150013-30d0-913a-e069-1b57-06ce1771347476253#4.1#10050271#0#0##","39","24.06","0","","25","Hate speech is often intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false"]],["4.1_2",["136696150013-a472-64d8-1969-a12c-240f1771345600848#4.1#10050271#0#0##","17.72","40.26","0","","25","Hate speech is often intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false"]],["4.1_3",["136696150013-9987-3bae-fe20-77c7-489d1771345638297#4.1#10050271#0#0##","4.43","2.45","0","","25","Hate speech is often intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false"]],["5.1_1",["136696150013-400e-11c8-f823-afde-c2081771347487245#5.1#10050271#0#0##","31.46","33.71","0","","25","Hate speech can also include unspoken pictures and symbols. For example,","false"]],["5.1_2",["136696150013-d275-98d2-cc26-3d21-1ad61771347501025#5.1#10050271#0#0##","58.7","59.42","0","","25","Hate speech can also include unspoken pictures and symbols. For example,","false"]],["6.1_1",["136696150013-9486-e73d-db46-9e77-10711771347510388#6.1#10050271#0#0##","41.82","19.68","0","","25","the Nazi swastika and the Confederate battle flag (of the Confederate States","false"]],["7.1_1",["136696150013-d1fd-edc5-70fc-3aec-16851771347519177#7.1#10050271#0#0##","42.18","53.48","0","","25","of America) have been considered hate speech by many people and groups.","false"]],["8.1_1",["136696150013-90f1-931e-767c-7bc2-5da61771347533215#8.1#10050271#0#0##","70.82","45.88","0","","25","Critics of hate speech argue that it causes psychological harm to its victims, and physical harm when it incites violence.","false"]],["9.1_1",["136696150013-5b3b-aef8-4538-f6b9-fd311771347757837#9.1#10050271#0#0##","20.1","44.36","0","","25","They also say that it makes its victims less equal in society. That is particularly true, they claim,","false"]],["9.1_2",["136696150013-7b75-d316-0e14-342b-cf9b1771347557216#9.1#10050271#0#0##","17.06","9.09","0","","25","They also say that it makes its victims less equal in society. That is particularly true, they claim,","false"]],["9.1_3",["136696150013-2c55-a38b-fabb-6f68-6bee1771347570559#9.1#10050271#0#0##","7.27","3.52","0","","25","They also say that it makes its victims less equal in society. That is particularly true, they claim,","false"]],["10.1_1",["136696150013-a969-f278-2af7-1bb2-84c61771347818957#10.1#10050271#0#0##","62.59","28.23","0","","25","because the social groups that are commonly the targets of hate speech have historically suffered from social marginalization and oppression.","false"]],["11.1_1",["136696150013-100b-0f28-d3f3-3585-45f01771347827987#11.1#10050271#0#0##","78.1","48.93","0","","25","Hate speech therefore poses a challenge for modern liberal societies,","false"]],["12.1_1",["136696150013-c0c1-7e54-b041-cd51-27e91771347836945#12.1#10050271#0#0##","30.57","14.52","0","","25","which are committed to both freedom of expression and social equality. Thus,","false"]],["12.1_2",["136696150013-beaa-aecf-5b80-cf4d-86e71771347847066#12.1#10050271#0#0##","40.99","16.88","0","","25","which are committed to both freedom of expression and social equality. Thus,","false"]],["13.1_1",["136696150013-13ab-c37b-20cd-23e9-05861771347859676#13.1#10050271#0#0##","40.69","42.8","0","","25","there is an ongoing debate in those societies over whether and how hate speech should be regulated or censored.","false"]],["13.1_2",["136696150013-af2f-770c-8e3b-549b-428c1771347870587#13.1#10050271#0#0##","31.59","34.55","0","","25","there is an ongoing debate in those societies over whether and how hate speech should be regulated or censored.","false"]],["14.1_1",["136696150013-e8de-cdba-69ea-4399-7c121771347879446#14.1#10050271#0#0##","6.69","18.15","0","","25","Censorship Is Worse Than Hate Speech","false"]],["14.1_2",["136696150013-7bc5-be8d-7077-4571-5c751771347886767#14.1#10050271#0#0##","20.4","29.77","0","","25","Censorship Is Worse Than Hate Speech","false",[["0.522","90",["EH=>I","ER=>I R","IH=>I"],"Censorship"]]]],["14.1_3",["136696150013-0c24-82d6-f913-0b09-ed681771347894995#14.1#10050271#0#0##","34.2","34.56","0","","25","Censorship Is Worse Than Hate Speech","false"]],["15.1_1",["136696150013-1618-b1bb-4246-d56b-d6471771347904554#15.1#10050271#0#0##","31.28","21.28","0","","25","In the idea of what traditional liberal, democratic societies should be,","false"]],["15.1_2",["136696150013-9c21-d7bb-9512-14f3-3a191771347915027#15.1#10050271#0#0##","23.87","49.12","0","","25","In the idea of what traditional liberal, democratic societies should be,","false"]],["16.1_1",["136696150013-7016-5569-b4ba-4d7f-21461771347930480#16.1#10050271#0#0##","25.29","26.8","0","","25","all speech is typically allowed under the ideal of \"freedom of expression.\" That often includes hate speech.","false"]],["16.1_2",["136696150013-4801-4199-ed5f-3678-f14b1771347945649#16.1#10050271#0#0##","35.8","12.82","0","","25","all speech is typically allowed under the ideal of \"freedom of expression.\" That often includes hate speech.","false"]],["17.1_1",["136696150013-04db-8abd-7609-7f7d-5f701771347954973#17.1#10050271#0#0##","7.86","23.4","0","","25","A person may be disgusted by hate speech,","false"]],["17.1_2",["136696150013-6915-7938-0934-ba22-66871771347960819#17.1#10050271#0#0##","2.46","14.51","0","","25","A person may be disgusted by hate speech,","false"]],["17.1_3",["136696150013-fd3b-0419-da71-55c2-ba9a1771347968965#17.1#10050271#0#0##","28.48","21.75","0","","25","A person may be disgusted by hate speech,","false"]],["18.1_1",["136696150013-8f60-7a6d-cc05-3520-59461771347987853#18.1#10050271#0#0##","47.3","25.41","0","","25","but they may also find it worse to allow their government to censor the words of a citizen,","false"]],["19.1_1",["136696150013-7e7c-27ff-4ba2-3f2a-2f011771348001509#19.1#10050271#0#0##","21.44","34.29","0","","25","even if those words are bigoted or hateful. Censorship, they might say, would lead to more censorship by a government.","false"]],["19.1_2",["136696150013-1185-ad08-0efd-e739-41041771348016206#19.1#10050271#0#0##","20.19","24.78","0","","25","even if those words are bigoted or hateful. Censorship, they might say, would lead to more censorship by a government.","false"]],["19.1_3",["136696150013-4724-8137-09ac-b133-820b1771348019956#19.1#10050271#0#0##","20.19","24.78","0","","25","even if those words are bigoted or hateful. Censorship, they might say, would lead to more censorship by a government.","false"]],["20.1_1",["136696150013-65b9-e037-712e-1b58-6e151771348041465#20.1#10050271#0#0##","25.08","38.23","0","","25","It could end up that legitimate but unpopular expression would be disallowed, such as criticism of government.","false",[["78.68","78.35",["DH=>D","IH=>I"],"This"]]]],["20.1_2",["136696150013-c2f3-1069-ae4f-01d1-89c31771348055961#20.1#10050271#0#0##","36.93","38.44","0","","25","It could end up that legitimate but unpopular expression would be disallowed, such as criticism of government.","false"]],["20.1_3",["136696150013-687e-50f3-ce18-f163-256a1771348070039#20.1#10050271#0#0##","16.89","21.22","0","","25","It could end up that legitimate but unpopular expression would be disallowed, such as criticism of government.","false"]],["21.1_1",["136696150013-fd9c-80bc-c672-2118-21c11771348160195#21.1#10050271#0#0##","58.68","51.93","0","","25","This would be unthinkable, as criticism of government is key to the political health of a liberal democracy.","false"]],["32.1_1",["136696150013-7265-2450-e23b-0af9-34381771350046627#32.1#10050271#0#0##","49.9","49.41","0","","25","hate speech is not just insulting it also continues the oppression of these minorities. It causes the victims,","false",[["77.504","86.88",["IH=>I"],"it"],["11.748000000000001","90",["Z=>S"],"is"],["1.1039999999999999","0",["DH=>D"],"these"],["73.968","90",["AH=>O"],"insulting"],["61.048","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"continues"],["63.152","90",["AH=>O"],"of"],["13.200000000000001","12",["AA=>U"],"not"],["10.878","90",["V=>B","Z=>S"],"victims"]]]],["33.1_1",["136696150013-d372-1a3e-5eef-563e-3ed71771350058587#33.1#10050271#0#0##","32.78","43.45","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large to internalize the hateful messages and act on that hate.","false",[["64.304","70.38",["U=>O"],"to"],["62.088","90",["O=>U"],"society"],["18.024","10.04",["DH=>D","EH=>I"],"them"],["0.126","90",["ER=>I R","Z=>S"],"internalize"]]]],["33.1_2",["136696150013-c6cb-b4fa-2d9a-09ec-7c401771350070645#33.1#10050271#0#0##","3.09","24.07","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large to internalize the hateful messages and act on that hate.","false"]],["33.1_3",["136696150013-9a23-18e6-239b-ad93-ce351771350084593#33.1#10050271#0#0##","33.04","49.44","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large to internalize the hateful messages and act on that hate.","false",[["3.258","0",["U=>O"],"to"],["4.542000000000001","90",["O=>U","IH=>I"],"society"],["75.144","83.93",["AE=>A"],"at"],["62.256","90",["IH=>I","ER=>I R","Z=>S"],"internalize"],["78.08800000000001","87.61",["AA=>U"],"on"],["67.34400000000001","90",["AE=>A"],"that"]]]],["34.1_1",["136696150013-ad0e-58e7-5bb7-f24d-23541771350106012#34.1#10050271#0#0##","2.45","15.47","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot enter the \"open marketplace of ideas\" as equal participants to defend themselves. For them,","false",[["0.126","0",["AE=>A","Z=>S"],"as"],["0.06","0",["IH=>I","IH=>I","SH=>S"],"discrimination"],["1.3980000000000001","0",["V=>B"],"themselves"]]]],["34.1_2",["136696150013-9dec-283e-eeca-99b5-a6021771350119299#34.1#10050271#0#0##","12.42","14.15","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot enter the \"open marketplace of ideas\" as equal participants to defend themselves. For them,","false",[["2.8680000000000003","90",["V=>B"],"victims"],["69.312","76.64",["DH=>D"],"the"],["23.622","90",["V=>B","Z=>S"],"themselves"]]]],["34.1_3",["136696150013-96e5-5abe-ac6e-437b-d92c1771350136238#34.1#10050271#0#0##","9.97","33.98","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot enter the \"open marketplace of ideas\" as equal participants to defend themselves. For them,","false",[["2.67","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"victims"],["0.5519999999999999","0",["DH=>D"],"the"],["5.868","0",["D=>JH"],"and"],["1.152","0",["DH=>D","EH=>I"],"them"],["61.84","57.3",["DH=>D","AE=>A"],"that"]]]],["35.1_1",["136696150013-cc08-b4d8-c989-89c4-4c561771350159969#35.1#10050271#0#0##","22.46","22.77","0","","25","hate speech, in addition to a broader system of inequality and unjust discrimination that burdens the victims, effectively silences them.","false",[["19.662000000000003","12.77",["IH=>I","SH=>S"],"addition"],["57.376000000000005","90",["U=>O"],"to"],["0.18600000000000003","90",["AO=>U","ER=>I R"],"broader"],["0.282","90",["IH=>I"],"system"],["1.59","0",["I=>IH"],"inequality"],["3.78","0",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"discrimination"],["0.126","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"victims"],["0.12","0",["E+I=>A"],"States"],["19.584000000000003","90",["DH=>D"],"them"]]]],["35.1_2",["136696150013-7748-d858-629a-03b4-6c1f1771350178445#35.1#10050271#0#0##","37.63","17.49","0","","25","hate speech, in addition to a broader system of inequality and unjust discrimination that burdens the victims, effectively silences them.","false",[["4.008","90",["IH=>I"],"in"],["0.36600000000000005","0",["IH=>I","SH=>S"],"addition"],["1.1039999999999999","90",["U=>O"],"to"],["18.108","90",["AO=>U","ER=>I R"],"broader"],["0.13799999999999998","90",["IH=>I"],"system"],["53.464","46.83",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"inequality"],["44.208","90",["AH=>O"],"unjust"],["0.87","90",["DH=>D","AE=>A"],"that"]]]],["35.1_3",["136696150013-7e36-843c-8fa1-c2ce-55691771350185979#35.1#10050271#0#0##","2.79","3.62","0","","25","hate speech, in addition to a broader system of inequality and unjust discrimination that burdens the victims, effectively silences them.","false"]],["36.1_1",["136696150013-0baa-e8a5-f953-cdcf-0b0d1771350212856#36.1#10050271#0#0##","31.68","31.77","0","","25","The court system of the United States has,","false",[["0.168","90",["IH=>I"],"system"],["45.856","47.32",["IH=>I"],"its"],["62.04","90",["AE=>A","Z=>S"],"has"]]]],["37.1_1",["136696150013-dd94-f2dc-2501-a653-5b0c1771350222387#37.1#10050271#0#0##","13","13.14","0","","25","on the basis of the First Amendment and its principle of freedom of speech,","false",[["1.986","90",["S=>SH"],"its"]]]],["37.1_2",["136696150013-ae99-78a7-1138-480f-13861771350231406#37.1#10050271#0#0##","35.92","37.07","0","","25","on the basis of the First Amendment and its principle of freedom of speech,","false",[["51.80800000000001","90",["V=>B"],"of"],["0.252","90",["I=>IH"],"speech"]]]],["38.1_1",["136696150013-cf70-d6e2-f913-4cf6-b5be1771350239689#38.1#10050271#0#0##","19.23","19.91","0","","25","generally ruled against attempts to censor hate speech.","false",[["34.016000000000005","22.52",["O=>U","I=>IH"],"only"]]]],["38.1_2",["136696150013-7d71-6abe-a892-b346-30871771350246386#38.1#10050271#0#0##","5.2","3.94","0","","25","generally ruled against attempts to censor hate speech.","false",[["0.39","90",["U=>O"],"to"],["11.292000000000002","8.82",["AA=>U"],"harm"],["3.8880000000000003","0",["A+I=>IH"],"incite"]]]],["38.1_3",["136696150013-b6f6-c38a-1aaf-282a-ce911771350249393#38.1#10050271#0#0##","5.2","3.94","0","","25","generally ruled against attempts to censor hate speech.","false",[["0.39","90",["U=>O"],"to"],["11.292000000000002","8.82",["AA=>U"],"harm"],["3.8880000000000003","0",["A+I=>IH"],"incite"]]]],["39.1_1",["136696150013-a0b5-5905-b3a0-979b-afce1771350267400#39.1#10050271#0#0##","15.71","34.92","0","","25","The only exceptions are if hate speech is being used to incite immediate harm to a person or group,","false",[["0.8160000000000001","90",["IH=>I","EH=>I"],"exceptions"],["77.304","76.63",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"],["62.736000000000004","68.42",["DH=>D"],"The"]]]],["39.1_2",["136696150013-d240-87f8-fa4d-dac6-3e591771350279349#39.1#10050271#0#0##","3.33","98.77","0","","25","The only exceptions are if hate speech is being used to incite immediate harm to a person or group,","false"]],["39.1_3",["136696150013-1fec-bab2-06ec-9323-128c1771350290288#39.1#10050271#0#0##","26.7","23.95","0","","25","The only exceptions are if hate speech is being used to incite immediate harm to a person or group,","false",[["74.432","83.04",["EH=>I"],"them"],["3.0180000000000002","0",["IH=>I","A+I=>IH"],"incite"],["77.568","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"],["17.256","90",["D=>JH"],"used"]]]],["40.1_1",["136696150013-1b10-7765-a4b9-225d-8bd31771350327976#40.1#10050271#0#0##","12.48","7.86","0","","25","or if someone uses \"fighting words\" when standing right in front of them.","false",[["0.192","90",["IH=>I"],"if"],["34.384","90",["AH=>O","AH=>O"],"someone"],["1.02","0",["AO=>U"],"laws"],["22.836000000000002","90",["ER=>I R","Z=>S"],"words"],["1.302","0",["AE=>A"],"standing"],["0.6000000000000001","0",["E+I=>A"],"hate"]]]]]}