{"speech_score":["1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1"],"media_score":[["0.1_1",["406858150129-bc10-f0e2-fbfe-346e-36841769772017752#0.1#10050174#0#0##","71.29","69.94","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that denigrates a person or persons","false",[["78.72000000000001","90",["SH=>S"],"expression"],["79.06400000000001","78.83",["AH=>O","V=>B"],"of"]]]],["1.1_1",["406858150129-71a1-e12a-be5a-7f84-ece81769772027690#1.1#10050174#0#0##","31.79","60.19","0","","25","on the basis of (alleged) membership in a social group identified by attributes such as race,","false",[["56.68","50.85",["I=>IH","EH=>I","SH=>S"],"orientation"],["2.0100000000000002","0",["O=>U","SH=>S"],"social"],["78.808","90",["U=>O"],"group"]]]],["1.1_2",["406858150129-a3e7-e13a-1a86-6278-78f61769772037200#1.1#10050174#0#0##","62.45","78.62","0","","25","on the basis of (alleged) membership in a social group identified by attributes such as race,","false",[["77.952","77.44",["O=>U","SH=>S"],"social"],["77.152","90",["EH=>I"],"identified"],["79.304","90",["AH=>O"],"such"]]]],["2.1_1",["406858150129-ce71-951e-aa23-038e-05f41769772045750#2.1#10050174#0#0##","92.85","76.41","0","","25","ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age,","false",[["75.152","90",["TH=>T"],"ethnicity"],["77.76","90",["EH=>I"],"orientation"],["78.656","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"religion"]]]],["3.1_1",["406858150129-a191-e8cc-891a-bc38-11831769772051529#3.1#10050174#0#0##","96.84","96.77","0","","25","physical or mental disability and others.","false"]],["4.1_1",["406858150129-c3c6-22a6-60ad-06ff-99f31769772058541#4.1#10050174#0#0##","82.53","84.03","0","","25","Typical hate speech involves epithets and slurs,","false"]],["5.1_1",["406858150129-b34a-d781-daec-6fa3-c0fa1769772064980#5.1#10050174#0#0##","67.52","69.6","0","","25","statements that promote malicious stereotypes","false",[["3.5460000000000003","0",["AO=>U"],"or"],["66.67999999999999","73.35",["U=>O"],"to"],["73.8","90",["O=>U"],"stereotypes"]]]],["6.1_1",["406858150129-d998-5d44-f4fd-1835-fcac1769772073379#6.1#10050174#0#0##","84.01","87.05","0","","25","and speech intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false",[["74.352","90",["V=>B"],"violence"]]]],["7.1_1",["406858150129-af5e-418b-f714-2b81-05431769772080380#7.1#10050174#0#0##","65.94","68.62","0","","25","Hate speech can also include nonverbal depictions and symbols.","false",[["0.126","0",["IH=>I","D=>JH"],"include"],["77.92000000000002","90",["SH=>S","Z=>S"],"depictions"]]]],["8.1_1",["406858150129-0a72-90ec-e439-529d-40281769772085040#8.1#10050174#0#0##","90","45.3","0","","25","For example,","false"]],["9.1_1",["406858150129-5ef2-eb55-880f-9e13-ffec1769772093060#9.1#10050174#0#0##","84.56","86.97","0","","25","the Nazi swastika and the Confederate battle flag (of the Confederate","false"]],["10.1_1",["406858150129-236d-0f69-1e07-5048-8e601769772102940#10.1#10050174#0#0##","65.84","72.45","0","","25","States of America) have been considered hate speech by a variety of people and groups.","false",[["75.67200000000001","90",["AH=>O"],"of"],["32.104000000000006","90",["IH=>I"],"been"]]]],["11.1_1",["406858150129-fcf8-c7da-55f5-abc1-878f1769772108200#11.1#10050174#0#0##","55.53","87.3","0","","25","Critics of hate speech argue not only","false",[["71.968","79.96",["IH=>I"],"it"]]]],["12.1_1",["406858150129-4cc5-6916-2969-5e07-cc241769772114461#12.1#10050174#0#0##","62.68","82.6","0","","25","that it causes psychological harm to its victims,","false",[["76.84","90",["IH=>I"],"its"],["22.302000000000003","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"victims"]]]],["13.1_1",["406858150129-7a45-fb6e-b4e7-96b9-2ada1769772119751#13.1#10050174#0#0##","73.96","69.35","0","","25","and physical harm when it incites violence,","false",[["15.696000000000002","90",["EH=>I"],"when"],["73.36","90",["V=>B"],"violence"]]]],["14.1_1",["406858150129-ab34-3662-1ed4-1db8-7f4b1769772123932#14.1#10050174#0#0##","96.09","96.09","0","","25","but also that it undermines","false"]],["15.1_1",["406858150129-7d53-46aa-e0c9-e6d2-55f91769772128990#15.1#10050174#0#0##","73.69","93.25","0","","25","the social equality of its victims.","false",[["73.424","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"victims"]]]],["16.1_1",["406858150129-df2a-4634-669e-efe4-ed121769772134420#16.1#10050174#0#0##","71.14","71.5","0","","25","That is particularly true, they claim,","false",[["78.904","90",["Z=>S"],"is"]]]],["17.1_1",["406858150129-bf31-5be2-69dc-e1df-8bcc1769772142050#17.1#10050174#0#0##","93.13","69.66","0","","25","because the social groups that are commonly the targets of","false",[["78.024","90",["IH=>I","AO=>U"],"because"],["74.856","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["2.334","90",["AH=>O"],"of"]]]],["18.1_1",["406858150129-ce0e-d781-1024-4b74-7deb1769772152036#18.1#10050174#0#0##","80.56","87.35","0","","25","hate speech have historically suffered from social marginalization and oppression.","false",[["75.176","90",["V=>B"],"have"],["71.392","90",["IH=>I","IH=>I"],"historically"],["78.69600000000001","90",["SH=>S"],"social"],["72.864","90",["Z=>S","E+I=>A","SH=>S"],"marginalization"]]]],["19.1_1",["406858150129-0c4b-e175-8902-229e-1adb1769772159890#19.1#10050174#0#0##","81.97","93.22","0","","25","Hate speech therefore poses a challenge for modern liberal societies,","false",[["79.024","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"societies"]]]],["20.1_1",["406858150129-bac1-7f85-6558-5e65-05991769772164522#20.1#10050174#0#0##","96.27","94.34","0","","25","which are committed to both freedom","false"]],["21.1_1",["406858150129-681c-e250-6d4e-3de6-951e1769772169750#21.1#10050174#0#0##","93.07","72.49","0","","25","of expression and social equality.","false",[["10.248000000000001","90",["AH=>O","V=>B"],"of"],["78.26400000000001","90",["SH=>S"],"expression"],["78.584","90",["SH=>S"],"social"]]]],["22.1_1",["406858150129-3964-99e5-49fd-00c2-f1781769772173520#22.1#10050174#0#0##","98.36","98.36","0","","25","Thus,","false"]],["23.1_1",["406858150129-db6e-6c67-14a0-2e9c-1bb11769772180111#23.1#10050174#0#0##","76.71","77.11","0","","25","there is an ongoing debate in those societies over whether","false",[["79.016","88.77",["IH=>I"],"is"],["74.784","73.48",["DH=>D","O=>U"],"those"],["0.18000000000000002","0",["AE=>A"],"an"]]]],["24.1_1",["406858150129-2633-3a8f-2c0a-495a-0ae01769772187411#24.1#10050174#0#0##","96.45","87.73","0","","25","and how hate speech should be regulated or censored.","false"]],["25.1_1",["406858150129-fd50-0c7e-fe65-b291-92d21769772193110#25.1#10050174#0#0##","95.13","92.08","0","","25","The traditional liberal position regarding hate","false",[["79.272","90",["IH=>I"],"regarding"]]]],["26.1_1",["406858150129-d2bf-62db-86bb-e1e2-bfc61769772201411#26.1#10050174#0#0##","79.87","84.52","0","","25","speech is to permit it under the auspices of freedom of expression.","false",[["79.168","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"],["72.816","81.02",["IH=>I"],"it"],["76.632","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["70.216","77.77",["DH=>D"],"Although"]]]],["27.1_1",["406858150129-5a4e-4a12-e30c-2c78-70321769772208310#27.1#10050174#0#0##","93.78","86.2","0","","25","Although those who take that position acknowledge","false",[["53.903999999999996","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["74.408","90",["AE=>A","IH=>I"],"acknowledge"]]]],["28.1_1",["406858150129-97f7-3c0d-4f8d-c888-ad671769772214230#28.1#10050174#0#0##","95.06","83.91","0","","25","the odious nature of the messages of hate speech,","false"]],["29.1_1",["406858150129-73e8-f621-2a24-0040-f3301769772220809#29.1#10050174#0#0##","95.34","85.3","0","","25","they maintain that state censorship is a cure","false",[["77.512","90",["DH=>D"],"that"]]]],["30.1_1",["406858150129-4df5-5bd4-5b8c-4723-1b001769772229380#30.1#10050174#0#0##","58.73","94.11","0","","25","that causes more harm than the disease of bigoted expression.","false"]],["31.1_1",["406858150129-9a7a-5564-7b2e-d2d3-fdb81769772237720#31.1#10050174#0#0##","70.34","90.72","0","","25","They fear that a principle of censorship will lead to","false",[["78.96000000000001","90",["EH=>I"],"lead"]]]],["32.1_1",["406858150129-76a3-78ac-1e36-be6f-46df1769772246351#32.1#10050174#0#0##","58.73","78.67","0","","25","the suppression of other unpopular but nevertheless legitimate expression,","false",[["77.248","90",["SH=>S"],"suppression"],["78.632","88.29",["IH=>I"],"legitimate"]]]],["33.1_1",["406858150129-12c2-efe6-15b2-644c-0fb91769772253371#33.1#10050174#0#0##","94.29","74.57","0","","25","perhaps even of the criticism of government,","false",[["3.294","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["52.264","90",["AH=>O"],"of"],["76.392","90",["AH=>O","ER=>I R"],"government"]]]],["34.1_1",["406858150129-e7c8-83df-d6a5-ff3d-50711769772260280#34.1#10050174#0#0##","82.01","94.67","0","","25","which is vital to the political health of liberal democracy.","false",[["78.75200000000001","90",["AH=>O"],"of"]]]],["35.1_1",["406858150129-3185-ee9e-bbe0-e513-12281769772266690#35.1#10050174#0#0##","68.6","80.73","0","","25","They argue that the best way to counter hate speech is to","false",[["76.16799999999999","85.21",["DH=>D"],"the"],["71.152","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"]]]],["36.1_1",["406858150129-94ad-dbe5-0da9-1d2c-1a061769772273840#36.1#10050174#0#0##","79.37","71.94","0","","25","demonstrate its falsity in the open marketplace of ideas.","false",[["74.504","73.13",["DH=>D","AE=>A"],"that"],["8.472","90",["AH=>O"],"of"]]]],["37.1_1",["406858150129-d0e3-c3f0-2c88-f979-f9531769772284520#37.1#10050174#0#0##","84.73","60.87","0","","25","Proponents of censorship typically argue that the traditional liberal position wrongly assumes the social","false",[["0.8400000000000001","90",["AH=>O"],"of"],["9.588","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["79.072","90",["IH=>I"],"position"],["68.288","90",["S=>SH"],"assumes"]]]],["38.1_1",["406858150129-5d6f-b2ce-f431-12bf-5d471769772298180#38.1#10050174#0#0##","77.84","86.33","0","","25","equality of persons and groups in society and neglects the fact that there are marginalized groups who are especially vulnerable to the evils of hate speech.","false",[["52.96000000000001","90",["AH=>O"],"of"],["65.11200000000001","90",["Z=>S"],"marginalized"]]]],["39.1_1",["406858150129-96d3-112e-14e3-64c5-a6001769772303811#39.1#10050174#0#0##","63.23","74.25","0","","25","Hate speech, they argue,","false"]],["40.1_1",["406858150129-0f26-973b-489a-b3f3-0d811769772308811#40.1#10050174#0#0##","94.82","67.25","0","","25","is not merely the expression of ideas,","false",[["57.104","90",["SH=>S"],"expression"],["19.698","90",["AH=>O","V=>B"],"of"]]]],["41.1_1",["406858150129-7c99-0f69-7c99-753c-3e8c1769772314219#41.1#10050174#0#0##","66.74","83.54","0","","25","but rather it is an effective","false",[["78.67200000000001","90",["ER=>I R"],"rather"],["77.928","90",["V=>B"],"effective"]]]],["42.1_1",["406858150129-ee4d-96a6-01cc-dff9-d63c1769772321030#42.1#10050174#0#0##","94.16","88.46","0","","25","means of socially subordinating its victims.","false",[["78.32000000000001","90",["AH=>O"],"of"],["79.4","90",["SH=>S"],"socially"],["78.06400000000001","90",["Z=>S"],"victims"]]]],["43.1_1",["406858150129-a26b-b02d-dd28-5e8e-42fd1769772327090#43.1#10050174#0#0##","93.14","78.31","0","","25","When aimed at historically oppressed minorities,","false"]],["44.1_1",["406858150129-ad57-307f-f006-a325-606d1769772333809#44.1#10050174#0#0##","74.06","83.67","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but","false",[["77.83200000000001","90",["IH=>I"],"is"],["78.23200000000001","90",["AH=>O"],"insulting"]]]],["45.1_1",["406858150129-4b2f-010f-4d0c-e046-91f31769772341139#45.1#10050174#0#0##","77.93","80.81","0","","25","also perpetuates their oppression by causing the victims,","false",[["13.32","90",["V=>B"],"victims"]]]],["46.1_1",["406858150129-116d-b511-6c01-09d6-e8531769772347140#46.1#10050174#0#0##","73.61","94.69","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large","false"]],["47.1_1",["406858150129-fef1-de75-9f66-76ad-d0f01769772354519#47.1#10050174#0#0##","93.17","81.65","0","","25","to internalize the hateful messages and act accordingly.","false",[["78.552","90",["Z=>S"],"internalize"],["72.224","90",["IH=>I"],"accordingly"]]]],["48.1_1",["406858150129-611c-d0df-13ec-a98c-29b01769772360950#48.1#10050174#0#0##","91.73","53.73","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot","false",[["78.024","90",["V=>B"],"Victims"]]]],["49.1_1",["406858150129-8d40-9852-f75b-0b97-93dc1769772389499#49.1#10050174#0#0##","71.65","62.54","0","","25","enter the \"open marketplace of ideas\"","false",[["78.44","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["69.60000000000001","77",["I=>IH"],"equal"],["0.12","90",["AH=>O","V=>B"],"of"]]]],["50.1_1",["406858150129-93fc-3b14-b65c-1297-3c3d1769772396759#50.1#10050174#0#0##","92.75","73.28","0","","25","as equal participants to defend themselves, because hate speech,","false",[["37.4","90",["AE=>A"],"as"],["76.00800000000001","90",["IH=>I"],"participants"],["78.632","90",["V=>B","Z=>S"],"themselves"]]]],["51.1_1",["406858150129-aec3-7b52-6ded-4cc6-0ee61769772402709#51.1#10050174#0#0##","92.2","69.91","0","","25","in conjunction with a broader system of inequality","false",[["10.302","90",["SH=>S"],"conjunction"],["79.104","90",["DH=>D"],"with"],["78.928","90",["IH=>I"],"system"],["78.69600000000001","90",["AH=>O"],"of"]]]],["52.1_1",["406858150129-6aa9-a27d-e82c-87c1-b5ee1769772408870#52.1#10050174#0#0##","58.22","89.68","0","","25","and unjust discrimination that burdens the victims,","false",[["77.08800000000001","90",["SH=>S"],"discrimination"],["70","90",["V=>B","IH=>I","IH=>I"],"victims"]]]],["53.1_1",["406858150129-826a-2bca-ac9e-d1a1-1bff1769772413600#53.1#10050174#0#0##","98.14","98.14","0","","25","effectively silences them.","false"]],["54.1_1",["406858150129-739d-a9ee-ee9f-6110-0b5d1769772418901#54.1#10050174#0#0##","63","69.86","0","","25","The court system of the United States has,","false",[["4.920000000000001","90",["AE=>A"],"has"]]]],["55.1_1",["406858150129-9124-35db-9c15-ea60-bd8b1769772424009#55.1#10050174#0#0##","77.22","95.55","0","","25","on the basis of the First Amendment","false"]],["56.1_1",["406858150129-35a7-a8c8-f194-a48f-a9c61769772428721#56.1#10050174#0#0##","72.92","78.89","0","","25","and its principle of freedom of speech,","false",[["78.32000000000001","90",["AH=>O"],"of"]]]],["57.1_1",["406858150129-ba9c-bc35-1b0c-1fa4-b02b1769772435022#57.1#10050174#0#0##","78.76","89.28","0","","25","generally ruled against attempts to censor hate speech.","false"]],["58.1_1",["406858150129-2f8b-75f8-bd00-1a04-1bbe1769772442240#58.1#10050174#0#0##","96.28","94.64","0","","25","Other liberal democracies such as France, Germany,","false",[["78.528","90",["AH=>O"],"such"]]]]]}