{"speech_score":["1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1","1"],"media_score":[["0.1_1",["116754130026-2d8f-0ea9-34d9-6cf5-73301706263195611#0.1#10050274#0#0##","81.67","63.06","0","","25","Hate speech is speech or expression that denigrates a person or persons","false",[["0.81","90",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"]]]],["1.1_1",["116754130026-e20e-e9ec-4785-75e1-07f01706263207553#1.1#10050274#0#0##","51.18","57.42","0","","25","on the basis of (alleged) membership in a social group identified by attributes such as race,","false",[["72","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["74.64800000000001","90",["V=>B"],"of"],["3.5460000000000003","0",["AE=>A"],"as"],["1.1460000000000001","0",["EH=>I"],"alleged"]]]],["2.1_1",["116754130026-5862-abcc-a382-84d8-c80c1706263219279#2.1#10050274#0#0##","83.09","85.35","0","","25","ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religion, age, physical or mental disability and others.","false",[["0.384","90",["I=>IH","SH=>S"],"orientation"],["75.816","90",["F=>P","Z=>S"],"physical"]]]],["3.1_1",["116754130026-747d-bfc9-4ad6-2d4a-fd3d1706263227954#3.1#10050274#0#0##","74.88","77.62","0","","25","Typical hate speech involves epithets and slurs,","false",[["0.144","0",["U=>O"],"to"]]]],["4.1_1",["116754130026-a353-b0bc-e7ac-37ae-d20b1706263239781#4.1#10050274#0#0##","23.04","53.61","0","","25","statements that promote malicious stereotypes and speech intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false",[["47.6","49.5",["IH=>I"],"incite"],["3.66","0",["U=>O"],"include"],["42.488","43.11",["U=>O"],"to"],["32.416000000000004","90",["V=>B"],"violence"]]]],["4.1_2",["116754130026-66e8-3c57-ef63-f273-663a1706263265931#4.1#10050274#0#0##","25.62","57.07","0","","25","statements that promote malicious stereotypes and speech intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false",[["3.504","0",["E+I=>A"],"Hate"],["73.376","81.72",["U=>O"],"include"],["0.13799999999999998","0",["S=>SH"],"also"]]]],["4.1_3",["116754130026-5562-03d3-5e1c-4cf4-6dc31706263283629#4.1#10050274#0#0##","78.88","72.38","0","","25","statements that promote malicious stereotypes and speech intended to incite hatred or violence against a group.","false",[["67.88","90",["EH=>I"],"stereotypes"],["0.264","0",["IH=>I","S=>SH"],"incite"]]]],["5.1_1",["116754130026-0b6a-a1f4-90b6-00ef-4c5b1706263296168#5.1#10050274#0#0##","83.05","70.41","0","","25","Hate speech can also include nonverbal depictions and symbols. For example,","false",[["0.16200000000000003","90",["D=>JH"],"and"]]]],["6.1_1",["116754130026-1c9b-b1aa-8a4f-b5af-b85f1706263307287#6.1#10050274#0#0##","80.14","76.46","0","","25","the Nazi swastika and the Confederate battle flag (of the Confederate","false",[["46.6","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["49","90",["I=>IH"],"Nazi"]]]],["7.1_1",["116754130026-3209-d5a8-34bd-4a1c-35601706263317975#7.1#10050274#0#0##","64.73","67.24","0","","25","States of America) have been considered hate speech by a variety of people and groups.","false"]],["8.1_1",["116754130026-28c7-8758-f46e-20f3-f0601706263329487#8.1#10050274#0#0##","49.36","72.26","0","","25","Critics of hate speech argue not only that it causes psychological harm to its victims,","false",[["72.728","80.91",["IH=>I"],"its"],["78.88","90",["Z=>S","Z=>S"],"causes"],["4.11","0",["A+I=>IH"],"incites"]]]],["9.1_1",["116754130026-83ed-9f97-88bf-fed4-de951706263342665#9.1#10050274#0#0##","64.02","80","0","","25","and physical harm when it incites violence, but also that it undermines the social equality of its victims.","false",[["77.328","90",["F=>P"],"physical"],["78.888","90",["V=>B"],"violence"],["77.24000000000001","86.55",["IH=>I"],"it"],["79.016","90",["V=>B"],"of"]]]],["10.1_1",["116754130026-713b-ef09-072b-4e86-40c61706263352927#10.1#10050274#0#0##","73.02","93.01","0","","25","That is particularly true, they claim,","false"]],["11.1_1",["116754130026-c54d-d671-e925-8453-922d1706263365541#11.1#10050274#0#0##","74.73","71.62","0","","25","because the social groups that are commonly the targets of hate speech have historically suffered from social marginalization and oppression.","false",[["72.96000000000001","90",["V=>B"],"have"]]]],["12.1_1",["116754130026-c005-88eb-2fd8-4d11-ede01706263377216#12.1#10050274#0#0##","61.6","76.77","0","","25","Hate speech therefore poses a challenge for modern liberal societies,","false",[["56.096000000000004","90",["I=>IH"],"speech"],["42.24","42.8",["AH=>O"],"Thus"]]]],["13.1_1",["116754130026-33ee-2f6f-12d5-8356-56ef1706263387530#13.1#10050274#0#0##","43.7","62.17","0","","25","which are committed to both freedom of expression and social equality. Thus,","false"]],["14.1_1",["116754130026-21bc-4524-5b61-c89b-bfa11706263401062#14.1#10050274#0#0##","50.59","78.63","0","","25","there is an ongoing debate in those societies over whether and how hate speech should be regulated or censored.","false",[["77.06400000000001","86.33",["IH=>I"],"is"],["36.344","35.43",["IH=>I"],"it"]]]],["15.1_1",["116754130026-a07c-c0c3-6986-6188-50531706263415162#15.1#10050274#0#0##","63.01","81.74","0","","25","The traditional liberal position regarding hate speech is to permit it under the auspices of freedom of expression.","false",[["79.328","90",["IH=>I"],"regarding"],["78.84","88.55",["Z=>S"],"is"],["61.864000000000004","67.33",["AE=>A"],"that"],["78.76","90",["V=>B"],"of"]]]],["16.1_1",["116754130026-5163-914e-5122-b1c4-fa161706263427904#16.1#10050274#0#0##","48.89","58.99","0","","25","Although those who take that position acknowledge the odious nature of the messages of hate speech,","false",[["78.76","90",["Z=>S"],"those"],["44.864000000000004","46.08",["I=>IH"],"odious"]]]],["17.1_1",["116754130026-1086-5a7e-1043-00f3-8c3b1706263446389#17.1#10050274#0#0##","67.72","77.16","0","","25","they maintain that state censorship is a cure that causes more harm than the disease of bigoted expression.","false",[["74.616","73.27",["IH=>I","Z=>S"],"is"],["77.34400000000001","90",["Z=>S","Z=>S"],"causes"],["70.296","77.87",["EH=>I"],"lead"],["0.18600000000000003","0",["DH=>D"],"than"]]]],["18.1_1",["116754130026-2e64-9d12-7a6d-946d-06071706263460399#18.1#10050274#0#0##","45.89","63.8","0","","25","They fear that a principle of censorship will lead to the suppression of other unpopular but nevertheless legitimate expression,","false",[["72.08","80.1",["DH=>D"],"that"],["0.246","0",["EH=>I"],"lead"],["0.126","0",["ER=>I R","DH=>D","S=>SH"],"nevertheless"]]]],["19.1_1",["116754130026-fb4f-c159-57b7-77ee-f25e1706263473368#19.1#10050274#0#0##","42.47","60.79","0","","25","perhaps even of the criticism of government, which is vital to the political health of liberal democracy.","false",[["16.71","17.85",["Z=>S"],"criticism"],["40.088","40.11",["DH=>D"],"the"],["78.304","90",["TH=>T"],"health"]]]],["20.1_1",["116754130026-1dbc-c271-ae9e-1afe-70821706263482567#20.1#10050274#0#0##","57.5","55.55","0","","25","They argue that the best way to counter hate speech is to","false",[["9.072000000000001","0",["AH=>O","V=>B"],"of"]]]],["21.1_1",["116754130026-a327-7bc5-2eeb-618d-f6d61706263492406#21.1#10050274#0#0##","65.41","75.78","0","","25","demonstrate its falsity in the open marketplace of ideas.","false",[["0.12","90",["DH=>D"],"the"],["71.49600000000001","90",["Z=>S"],"ideas"]]]],["22.1_1",["116754130026-bcf3-30d8-085e-719f-05a11706263508874#22.1#10050274#0#0##","58.92","54.65","0","","25","Proponents of censorship typically argue that the traditional liberal position wrongly assumes the social","false",[["71.56","79.45",["U=>O"],"to"],["0.126","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["0.9720000000000001","0",["S=>SH","U=>O"],"assumes"]]]],["23.1_1",["116754130026-3296-5e0f-b5a3-5459-aaa81706263524812#23.1#10050274#0#0##","48.36","51.24","0","","25","equality of persons and groups in society and neglects the fact that there are marginalized groups who are especially vulnerable to the evils of hate speech.","false",[["0.558","90",["U=>O"],"groups"],["71.592","79.49",["DH=>D"],"that"],["6.0120000000000005","90",["DH=>D"],"there"],["8.459999999999999","4.1",["AA=>U"],"are"],["0.15000000000000002","0",["V=>B","AH=>O"],"vulnerable"],["61.224000000000004","66.53",["IH=>I"],"in"]]]],["24.1_1",["116754130026-89c9-10c0-d4cc-a2e5-eb091706263535689#24.1#10050274#0#0##","70.19","60.42","0","","25","Hate speech, they argue, is not merely the expression of ideas,","false",[["1.29","90",["E+I=>A"],"Hate"],["46.504000000000005","48.13",["Z=>S"],"means"],["77.38400000000001","90",["Z=>S"],"is"],["76.632","90",["V=>B"],"of"]]]],["25.1_1",["116754130026-67bf-a31b-a859-a6af-942f1706263554222#25.1#10050274#0#0##","86.3","78.54","0","","25","but rather it is an effective means of socially subordinating its victims. When aimed at historically oppressed minorities,","false",[["77.736","87.17",["DH=>D"],"the"],["79.18400000000001","90",["Z=>S"],"is"],["12.258000000000001","90",["V=>B"],"effective"],["45.92","90",["AH=>O"],"of"]]]],["26.1_1",["116754130026-4992-1aea-bac8-c2c3-2a861706263567818#26.1#10050274#0#0##","59.03","56.43","0","","25","hate speech is not merely insulting but also perpetuates their oppression by causing the victims,","false",[["21.726","26.21",["AE=>A"],"at"],["11.73","90",["AH=>O"],"insulting"],["78.40800000000002","90",["S=>SH"],"also"],["12.21","90",["Z=>S"],"causing"],["2.952","90",["V=>B"],"victims"]]]],["27.1_1",["116754130026-e421-9014-78e9-110b-8b8e1706263579376#27.1#10050274#0#0##","61.36","53.51","0","","25","the perpetrators and society at large to internalize the hateful messages and act accordingly.","false",[["77.06400000000001","86.33",["U=>O"],"to"],["78.72800000000001","88.41",["AE=>A"],"at"]]]],["28.1_1",["116754130026-1915-4763-9d35-312c-5ece1706263596501#28.1#10050274#0#0##","52.41","62.1","0","","25","Victims of hate speech cannot enter the \"open marketplace of ideas\" as equal participants to defend themselves, because hate speech,","false",[["0.21000000000000002","90",["V=>B"],"victims"],["0.132","0",["AH=>O"],"unjust"]]]],["29.1_1",["116754130026-8e51-9c91-2c56-072b-80b81706263611201#29.1#10050274#0#0##","49.21","54.63","0","","25","in conjunction with a broader system of inequality and unjust discrimination that burdens the victims, effectively silences them.","false",[["39.344","90",["AH=>O"],"conjunction"],["0.504","0",["E+I=>A"],"States"],["75.104","90",["DH=>D"],"that"],["19.308000000000003","90",["V=>B"],"victims"],["9.954","6.59",["DH=>D"],"them"]]]],["30.1_1",["116754130026-ea9a-72c4-b540-190a-b5d91706263620550#30.1#10050274#0#0##","47.31","63.41","0","","25","The court system of the United States has,","false",[["0.954","0",["EH=>I"],"Amendment"],["74.368","90",["AE=>A"],"has"]]]],["31.1_1",["116754130026-3127-5a29-6184-0b36-ad831706263630076#31.1#10050274#0#0##","43.77","74.11","0","","25","on the basis of the First Amendment and its principle of freedom of speech,","false",[["78.12","77.65",["IH=>I","S=>SH"],"its"]]]],["32.1_1",["116754130026-eb68-fe4b-ff36-8ee3-d1eb1706263642181#32.1#10050274#0#0##","71.19","75.63","0","","25","generally ruled against attempts to censor hate speech. Other liberal democracies such as France, Germany,","false",[["78.512","90",["Z=>S"],"democracies"]]]],["33.1_1",["116754130026-c627-0d0e-e13d-0250-d7921706263656331#33.1#10050274#0#0##","59.67","65.47","0","","25","Canada and New Zealand have laws designed to curtail hate speech. Such laws have proliferated since World War II.","false",[["0.132","90",["U=>O"],"New"],["79.168","90",["Z=>S"],"laws"],["0.37200000000000005","0",["AO=>U"],"War"],["18.282","20.47",["E+I=>A"],"hate"],["2.6820000000000004","0",["ER=>I R","E+I=>A"],"curtail"]]]]]}