The D|AX judge&rsquos decision JH|IH|S|IH|ZH|AX|N D|I|S|I|ZH|AX|N JH|I|S|I|ZH|AX|N D|IH|SH|IH|SH|AX|N JH|IH|SH|IH|SH|AX|N D|I|SH|I|SH|AX|N JH|I|SH|I|SH|AX|N that D|AE|T DH|A|T D|A|T the D|AX tenant T|I|N|AX|N|T was W|U|Z W|AA|S W|U|S responsible R|IH|S|P|AA|N|S|AX|B|AX|L R|I|SH|P|AA|N|SH|AX|B|AX|L R|IH|SH|P|AA|N|SH|AX|B|AX|L R|I|S|P|U|N|S|AX|B|AX|L R|IH|S|P|U|N|S|AX|B|AX|L R|I|SH|P|U|N|SH|AX|B|AX|L R|IH|SH|P|U|N|SH|AX|B|AX|L for P|AO|R F|U|R P|U|R repairing R|I|P|I|R|I|NG the D|AX damage JH|AE|M|AX|JH D|A|M|AX|JH JH|A|M|AX|JH was W|U|Z W|AA|S W|U|S based B|A|S|T B|E + I|SH|T B|A|SH|T solely SH|O|AX|L|I S|U|AX|L|I SH|U|AX|L|I S|O|AX|L|IH SH|O|AX|L|IH S|U|AX|L|IH SH|U|AX|L|IH on U|N circumstantial SH|ER|K|AX|M|SH|T|AE|N|SH|AX|L S|I R|K|AX|M|S|T|AE|N|SH|AX|L SH|I R|K|AX|M|SH|T|AE|N|SH|AX|L S|ER|K|AX|M|S|T|A|N|SH|AX|L SH|ER|K|AX|M|SH|T|A|N|SH|AX|L S|I R|K|AX|M|S|T|A|N|SH|AX|L SH|I R|K|AX|M|SH|T|A|N|SH|AX|L S|ER|K|AX|M|S|T|AE|N|S|AX|L SH|ER|K|AX|M|SH|T|AE|N|S|AX|L S|I R|K|AX|M|S|T|AE|N|S|AX|L SH|I R|K|AX|M|SH|T|AE|N|S|AX|L S|ER|K|AX|M|S|T|A|N|S|AX|L SH|ER|K|AX|M|SH|T|A|N|S|AX|L S|I R|K|AX|M|S|T|A|N|S|AX|L SH|I R|K|AX|M|SH|T|A|N|S|AX|L evidence I|V|AX|D|AX|N|S EH|B|AX|D|AX|N|S I|B|AX|D|AX|N|S EH|V|AX|JH|AX|N|S I|V|AX|JH|AX|N|S EH|B|AX|JH|AX|N|S I|B|AX|JH|AX|N|S EH|V|AX|D|AX|N|SH I|V|AX|D|AX|N|SH EH|B|AX|D|AX|N|SH I|B|AX|D|AX|N|SH EH|V|AX|JH|AX|N|SH I|V|AX|JH|AX|N|SH EH|B|AX|JH|AX|N|SH I|B|AX|JH|AX|N|SH